Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF vs Vanguard High Dividend Yield Index Fund ETF Shares

SCHD vs VYM: how much do they really differ?

Companies making up 99.3% of SCHD are also in VYM, yet only 21.8% of VYM is inside SCHD. Over ten years SCHD's yearly return was +1.9 points ahead, while over five years the gap was −1.0 points.

Holdings and prices as of 20 November 2026. Updated after each market close.

Full holdings: SCHD holdings VYM holdings Check any two ETFs

The two funds side by side

SCHD, the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF, picks about a hundred US companies with long dividend records and screens them on quality measures such as cash flow and return on equity, then reshuffles the list once a year. VYM, the Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF, takes a much wider route: it holds almost every large US company expected to pay an above-average dividend, weighted by company size.

SCHDSchwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETFVYMVanguard High Dividend Yield Index Fund ETF Shares
Holdings97592
Top 10 weight41.4%25.6%
Largest holding
Procter & Gamble Company4.5% of the fund
Broadcom Inc6.7% of the fund
Largest sectorConsumer Defensive20.6%Financial Services21.3%
Fund size$123.7 billion$84.0 billion
Launched20112006
Clone a SCHD and VYM mix and edit it Opens the builder with SCHD and VYM at 50% each. Free account, no card.

How much they overlap

SCHD holds 97 companies and VYM holds 592. They share 78 of them, and measured by weight the overlap is 21.8%.

Overlap by weight21.8%held by both funds
Shared holdings78companies in both
SCHD also in VYM99.3%of SCHD's weight
VYM also in SCHD21.8%of VYM's weight
Largest shared holdingsIn SCHDIn VYM
Chevron CorpCVX
4.15%1.58%
The Coca-Cola CompanyKO
4.19%1.50%
Procter & Gamble CompanyPG
4.60%1.48%
Merck & Company IncMRK
3.77%1.47%
UnitedHealth Group IncorporatedUNH
3.96%1.37%
The Home Depot IncHD
4.43%1.22%
Texas Instruments IncorporatedTXN
4.44%1.06%
Amgen IncAMGN
4.31%0.94%
Qualcomm IncorporatedQCOM
3.91%0.83%
Verizon Communications IncVZ
3.76%0.83%

Overlap by weight adds up, for every company both funds hold, the smaller of its two weights. Weights as of 20 November 2026.

That two-way figure hides the real story, which is one-sided. Companies making up 99.3% of SCHD are also in VYM. The few SCHD names VYM lacks are tiny positions. So SCHD is, in effect, a concentrated slice of VYM's list.

Going the other way, companies worth only 21.8% of VYM appear in SCHD. The rest of VYM is names SCHD leaves out, and they include its biggest: VYM's largest holding is Broadcom Inc at 6.7%, and neither it nor JPMorgan Chase is in SCHD. That is why VYM's largest sector is Financial Services, while SCHD's is Consumer Defensive.

The shared companies also sit at very different weights. Procter & Gamble, Coca-Cola, Chevron and Merck each carry roughly three times the weight in SCHD that they do in VYM. SCHD's top 10 are 41.4% of the fund against 25.6% for VYM's. To check any other pair, use the ETF overlap tool.

How they performed

The backtest starts each fund with $10,000 and compares them over one, five and ten years.

SCHDVYM
$10k$20k$30k2017201820192020202120222023202420252026
1 year5 years10 years
Ending value of $10,000
SCHD$13,197$15,498$33,295
VYM$11,387$16,203$28,176
Yearly return
SCHD32.0%9.2%12.8%
VYM13.9%10.1%10.9%
Volatility
SCHD12.0%14.5%16.8%
VYM11.2%14.0%16.3%
Worst drop
SCHD6.9%16.8%33.4%
VYM7.4%15.8%35.2%
Correlation of daily returns
Both0.730.920.96

Windows end 20 November 2026. Dividends are included. A correlation of 1.00 means the two moved exactly together. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.

Over ten years SCHD returned 12.8% a year against 10.9% for VYM, a gap of +1.9 points. Over five years the order flipped, at −1.0 points, and over the last year SCHD led by +18.1 points.

That last gap is unusually wide for two dividend funds, and it shows in how they moved together. Their correlation was 0.96 over ten years but only 0.73 over the last year. Part of the reason is what each fund holds: SCHD's ten largest holdings sit at similar weights across consumer staples, health care, energy and technology, while VYM's largest positions are a chipmaker and a bank. When one sector runs far ahead, a fund with a few fixed, heavy bets can pull away from a broad one in either direction.

Swings like this cut both ways, and the five-year result is the reminder. Past results depend heavily on the period you pick.

Clone a SCHD and VYM mix and edit it Opens the builder with SCHD and VYM at 50% each. Free account, no card.

What the choice comes down to

  • Spread. VYM holds several hundred companies across every sector that pays a dividend, banks and large tech included (see the VYM holdings page for its top 10). SCHD holds about a hundred that pass its screens. For a fund that screens on dividend growth instead of yield, see VIG vs VYM. For SCHD against the whole market, see SCHD vs VOO.
  • Concentration. SCHD's top 10 are a larger share of the fund, so a handful of companies and sectors decide more of its result, as the last year showed.
  • Doubling up. Almost all of SCHD is already inside VYM, so holding both mostly adds weight to SCHD's picks rather than new companies. See the SCHD top 10 holdings for the full list.
  • The yearly reshuffle. SCHD's list changes at each annual rebalance, which can swap sectors in and out at once. VYM changes more gradually.
  • Your own mix. If you want something in between, you can build it: start from VYM, tilt toward the SCHD names you prefer, and backtest it against both funds, or read how rebalancing changes the result.

Questions about SCHD and VYM

What is the difference between SCHD and VYM?

SCHD holds about a hundred US companies picked for long dividend records and quality screens, with the list reset once a year. VYM holds several hundred companies with above-average yields, weighted by size, so it is broader and includes large banks and tech firms that SCHD leaves out.

How much do SCHD and VYM overlap?

As of 20 November 2026, the overlap by weight is 21.8%, but companies making up 99.3% of SCHD are also held by VYM. Almost all of SCHD is inside VYM; most of VYM is not inside SCHD.

Has SCHD done better than VYM?

Over ten years SCHD's yearly return was +1.9 points higher, over five years it was −1.0 points, and over the last year +18.1 points. The lead has changed hands, and past returns do not tell you what comes next.

Is it worth holding both SCHD and VYM?

Holding both mainly adds weight to the companies SCHD picks, since nearly all of them are already in VYM. Whether that suits you depends on how concentrated you want to be; you can test the mix in a backtest.

Why is Broadcom in VYM but not in SCHD?

VYM includes any large company forecast to pay an above-average dividend, weighted by size, which brings in Broadcom. SCHD scores companies on a mix that includes dividend yield and dividend growth and keeps only about a hundred, so Broadcom does not make its list.

Clone a SCHD and VYM mix and edit it Opens the builder with SCHD and VYM at 50% each. Free account, no card.

About this page. Holdings, weights and prices come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.