Free calculator · no signup
Enter what each holding is worth and the weight you want, and get the exact trades to get back on target. Use new cash to rebalance without selling, then see what each rebalancing rule really cost over 20 years once fees and tax are counted.
You pick a mix, say 60% stocks and 40% bonds, because it matches the risk you're willing to take. Then markets move. After a few good years for stocks you might be at 70/30 without having made a single decision, and carrying more risk than you signed up for. Rebalancing means trading back to your target mix: trimming what has grown too large and topping up what has fallen behind.
It's the same for a portfolio of individual stocks. One big winner can quietly grow from an eighth of your money to a third, and your portfolio starts to rise and fall with a single company.
There are two families of rules. Calendar rebalancing trades back to target on a schedule: monthly, quarterly, every six months or once a year. It's simple to follow but trades even when little has changed. Threshold rebalancing (also called band or tolerance rebalancing) only trades when a holding drifts a set distance from target, such as 5 or 10 percentage points. It does nothing in calm markets and acts quickly in fast ones.
Most guides stop at "once a year is fine." The question that matters is what each rule costs once you pay to trade and pay tax on the gains you realise, and almost nobody publishes that. So we ran the numbers.
Original research
We tested seven rules on two portfolios with our costs engine, the same one inside Indices Lab: a classic 60/40 split between the S&P 500 (SPY) and US bonds (AGG) since 2004, and eight large US companies held in equal weights since 2005 (Apple, Microsoft, Johnson & Johnson, ExxonMobil, Procter & Gamble, Coca-Cola, JPMorgan and Walmart). Each run starts with $100,000 in a taxable account, pays 0.1% on every trade, 20% tax on realised gains and 15% on dividends, and sells everything at the end so the after-tax figure is money you could actually spend.
| Rebalance | Return before costs | After costs & tax | Lost / yr | End value after tax | Trades / yr | Volatility | Worst fall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Never | 8.97% | 7.75% | 1.22 | $546,785 | 0.1 | 12.5% | -34.1% |
| Yearly | 8.04% | 6.70% | 1.34 | $436,843 | 2.0 | 10.9% | -33.7% |
| Every 6 months | 7.95% | 6.59% | 1.36 | $426,786 | 4.0 | 11.0% | -34.5% |
| Quarterly | 7.98% | 6.59% | 1.40 | $426,717 | 8.1 | 11.1% | -35.0% |
| Monthly | 7.89% | 6.45% | 1.45 | $414,163 | 24.1 | 11.2% | -35.8% |
| 5-point band | 8.10% | 6.75% | 1.35 | $442,223 | 1.7 | 11.5% | -35.1% |
| 10-point band | 8.27% | 6.94% | 1.33 | $460,376 | 0.5 | 11.7% | -35.1% |
Swipe the table sideways for every column →
| Rebalance | Return before costs | After costs & tax | Lost / yr | End value after tax | Trades / yr | Volatility | Worst fall |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Never | 20.13% | 18.73% | 1.41 | $4,179,150 | 0.4 | 22.7% | -45.6% |
| Yearly | 15.43% | 13.26% | 2.17 | $1,499,315 | 8.1 | 16.6% | -38.6% |
| Every 6 months | 15.28% | 13.03% | 2.25 | $1,433,490 | 16.2 | 16.6% | -39.3% |
| Quarterly | 15.27% | 12.90% | 2.36 | $1,399,341 | 32.4 | 16.6% | -38.7% |
| Monthly | 15.01% | 12.48% | 2.53 | $1,289,991 | 96.4 | 16.6% | -39.0% |
| 5-point band | 15.34% | 13.18% | 2.16 | $1,477,283 | 6.6 | 16.7% | -38.4% |
| 10-point band | 15.34% | 13.41% | 1.93 | $1,542,778 | 2.6 | 16.7% | -39.0% |
Swipe the table sideways for every column →
Returns are yearly (CAGR). "Before costs" is the return with no fees or tax, using prices with dividends reinvested. "After costs & tax" pays 0.1% per trade, 20% on realised gains and 15% on dividends, and sells everything on the last day. "Lost / yr" is the gap between the two, in percentage points. A 5- or 10-point band means the portfolio is rebalanced only when a weight drifts that far from target. Bands are checked every trading day and rebalance all holdings once any weight is more than the band away from target. Hypothetical results; past performance doesn't guarantee future results.
In a tax-advantaged account, like an IRA, 401(k) or ISA, the tax part largely disappears and the "before costs" column is closer to what you'd get. The case for rebalancing less often is strongest in a taxable account.
A band of 5 percentage points is a common starting point: with a 60% target, you'd act below 55% or above 65%. Wider bands, like 10 points, trade less and in our study kept more after tax, at the cost of letting the mix wander further. For small positions, a fixed number of points is too loose, which is why many investors use the 5/25 rule: rebalance at 5 points of drift, or 25% of the target weight, whichever comes first. A 4% holding would be rebalanced at 3% or 5%.
Whatever you choose, the best rule is one you'll follow. Checking once a quarter against your band is plenty for most people.
Save your portfolio as an index and Indices Lab keeps an eye on it for you: live tracking shows how far each holding has drifted, alerts tell you when one crosses your band, and the rebalance planner works out the trades, including buy-only rebalancing with your next contribution. Backtests let you compare calendar and threshold rules on your own holdings, with trading costs and tax switched on.
Want to check what you own first? Run your holdings through the free portfolio analyzer, compare rules with the portfolio backtest, or let the portfolio optimizer suggest target weights.
FAQ
For most long-term investors, once a year or when a holding drifts a set amount from target is enough. In our study of a 60/40 portfolio since 2004, rebalancing monthly instead of yearly added trades and tax but no extra return. More often isn't better once costs and tax are counted.
A simple rule is to rebalance when any holding drifts more than 5 percentage points from its target, or on a fixed date each year, whichever you'll actually stick to. Rebalancing with new money, by buying whatever is underweight, lets you rebalance whenever you add cash without selling.
Threshold (or band) rebalancing means you only trade when a holding moves outside a band around its target, for example 5 points either side. If your target is 60% stocks, you'd rebalance when stocks rise above 65% or fall below 55%. It tends to trade less than a calendar rule because nothing happens in quiet markets.
A rule of thumb popularised by Larry Swedroe: rebalance a holding when it drifts 5 percentage points from target, or 25% of its target weight, whichever comes first. The 25% part matters for small positions, so a 4% holding is rebalanced at 3% or 5% rather than waiting for a 5-point move.
In a taxable account, selling a holding that has gained value usually realises a capital gain, and tax is due on it. That's why rebalancing often costs more than it looks. Rebalancing inside tax-advantaged accounts, or rebalancing by directing new cash to underweight holdings, avoids most of it.
Tax drag is the return you lose each year to taxes on realised gains and dividends. Every time you sell a winner to rebalance, part of the gain goes to tax instead of staying invested and compounding. In our study, monthly rebalancing of eight stocks lost about 2.5 points a year to costs and tax, versus 1.4 for never rebalancing.
Yes. Add new money only to the holdings that are below target, and take withdrawals from those above it. The calculator's Buy only mode works out exactly how to split a deposit, and tells you how much cash it would take to reach target without selling anything.
Not reliably. When one asset keeps outperforming, rebalancing sells it and usually lowers the return. What rebalancing does is keep your risk where you chose it: in our 60/40 study, yearly rebalancing cut volatility from 12.5% to 10.9%.
No. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool. The calculator and study describe hypothetical trades and past results, and aren't a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Tax rules depend on where you live and your account type.
Save your portfolio, get an alert when it drifts, and rebalance with your next deposit. Free to start.
Get started free →