Guide

Factor investing explained: quality, momentum and low volatility, tested

Factor investing means buying stocks for a shared trait, such as strong profits (quality), recent price gains (momentum) or calm prices (low volatility), in the hope of doing better than the whole market. From 18 July 2013 to 20 November 2026, the quality fund QUAL grew 12.9% a year, the momentum fund MTUM 13.1% and the low volatility fund USMV 10.3%, against 13.0% for SPY.

What a factor is

A factor is a trait that a group of stocks share and that has been linked, in decades of research, to returns that differ from the market's. Factor investing means building a portfolio around one or more of those traits instead of simply owning every company in proportion to its size. Owning every company by size is called market-cap weighting, and it is what SPY, the S&P 500 fund, does. Factor funds are also called smart beta funds: rule-based like an index fund, with a tilt.

This guide tests three factors, each through one well-known US fund:

  • Quality: companies with high profits on their capital, steady earnings and little debt. The fund here is QUAL.
  • Momentum: stocks whose prices have risen most over the past year or so, on the idea that recent winners keep winning for a while. The fund here is MTUM.
  • Low volatility: stocks, and a mix of them, chosen to swing less than the market. The fund here is USMV.

Two other well-known factors, value (cheap stocks) and size (small companies), are left out here; we tested value in value vs growth.

Every factor fund is built in the same basic steps, each a choice that changes the result:

How a factor fund is built

  1. 1Start with a broad list of stocks
  2. 2Score each stock on one trait
  3. 3Keep the best-scoring stocks
  4. 4Weight them by a fixed rule
  5. 5Re-pick them on a schedule

The follow-along example

We hold each fund on its own, with dividends reinvested, from 18 July 2013 to 20 November 2026, each starting with $10,000. The start date is the first day all four funds have prices.

Follow along: the four portfolios

Portfolio Factor Rule
QUAL Quality Held as one fund
MTUM Momentum Held as one fund
USMV Low volatility Held as one fund
SPY None: the whole market by size Held as one fund; our benchmark

The benchmark is the yardstick every factor fund is measured against: if a factor fund can't beat it over the same dates, the tilt hasn't paid for itself.

How we tested this

DataDaily prices adjusted for splits and dividends (total return) for QUAL, MTUM, USMV and SPY, from EODHD.
Period18 July 2013 to 20 November 2026, the longest period every holding has prices for
BasketsQUAL (quality): QUAL 100%, held throughout; MTUM (momentum): MTUM 100%, held throughout; USMV (low volatility): USMV 100%, held throughout; SPY (the market): SPY 100%, held throughout (benchmark)
How we testedEach fund starts with $10,000 on the first day all four have a common history and is held on its own, with no rebalancing. SPY is the benchmark. Rolling windows start once a month; the two halves split the history at its midpoint.
Not includedTrading costs and taxes; fund fees are already in each fund's price. The value and size factors, other providers' factor funds, and crashes before 2013, including 2008, are outside this test.

Step 1: Compare growth over the whole period

Start simple: where did $10,000 end up? Read the growth rate as CAGR, the compound annual growth rate: the steady yearly rate that turns the start value into the end value (how CAGR works).

QUAL (quality)MTUM (momentum)USMV (low volatility)SPY (the market)
Growth of $10,000, full period: QUAL (quality) $50,765, MTUM (momentum) $51,945, USMV (low volatility) $37,173, SPY (the market) $51,066$20k$40k$60k2014201620182020202220242026
  • QUAL (quality) $50,765
  • MTUM (momentum) $51,945
  • USMV (low volatility) $37,173
  • SPY (the market) $51,066

Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 18 July 2013 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.

Follow along: the whole period

Portfolio CAGR Gap to SPY, per year End value
QUAL 12.9% −0.1 points $50,765
MTUM 13.1% +0.1 points $51,945
USMV 10.3% −2.7 points $37,173
SPY 13.0% $51,066

The first surprise: after more than a decade, quality and momentum ended close to the plain market fund, and low volatility ended well behind it. A premium found in long academic histories does not promise one in the years you own the fund.

Step 2: Weigh the return against the ride

A lower return is not automatically worse if it came with a calmer ride. Volatility measures how much a portfolio swings up and down, as a yearly percentage. The Sharpe ratio divides return by volatility, so higher means more return for each unit of swing; the Sortino ratio does the same but counts only the downward swings (the three ratios compared).

BasketYearly returnVolatilitySharpeWorst drop$10,000 became
QUAL (quality)12.9%17.0%0.8034.1%$50,765
MTUM (momentum)13.1%20.6%0.7034.1%$51,945
USMV (low volatility)10.3%13.7%0.7933.1%$37,173
SPY (the market)13.0%17.0%0.8133.7%$51,066

Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 18 July 2013 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns. Sharpe uses a 0% risk-free rate.

Follow along: return per unit of risk

Portfolio Volatility Sharpe Sortino
QUAL 17.0% 0.80 1.14
MTUM 20.6% 0.70 0.98
USMV 13.7% 0.79 1.11
SPY 17.0% 0.81 1.13

USMV did what its name says: it swung the least of the four, and its Sharpe ratio stayed close to SPY's. So it gave up growth but not much return per unit of swing. MTUM swung the most and had the lowest Sharpe ratio: its small lead in growth came with a bumpier ride.

Step 3: Check every start date, not just one

One start date can flatter or punish any fund. A rolling window test takes every possible 5-year or 10-year stretch, one per month, and counts how often the factor fund finished ahead of SPY. For QUAL, the chart shows a 10-year gap to SPY that stayed small in every window, ahead in some and behind in more.

QUAL (quality) aheadSPY (the market) ahead
QUAL (quality) minus SPY (the market), annualised return over every rolling 10-year window: QUAL (quality) ahead in 36.6% of 41 windows-1 pts0 pts202420252026

QUAL (quality) finished ahead of SPY (the market) in 36.6% of 41 rolling 10-year windows (window ends by month). The last window QUAL (quality) won ended November 2024.

Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 18 July 2013 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.

Follow along: how often each factor fund beat SPY

Portfolio Ahead in 5-year windows Ahead in 10-year windows 5-year gap, worst to best (per year)
QUAL 33.7% of 101 36.6% of 41 −1.7 points to +0.9 points
MTUM 47.5% of 101 68.3% of 41 −5.3 points to +4.8 points
USMV 20.8% of 101 0.0% of 41 −7.1 points to +3.1 points

Momentum led SPY in most 10-year windows but in fewer than half of the 5-year ones, and its 5-year gap swung widely in both directions. That is the shape of most factors: long stretches behind the market are normal, even for a factor that wins in the end.

A trap in the 10-year column: with this much history, the 10-year windows all start within a few years of each other, so they share most of their years. Treat that win share as one long result, not dozens of independent tests.

Clone this example Opens the builder with QUAL 100% against SPY (the market). Free account, no card.

Step 4: Split the history in two

A factor can earn its lead in one era and give it back in the next, so split the test at its midpoint.

Follow along: growth per year in each half

Portfolio First half Second half
QUAL 8.3% 17.8%
MTUM 11.1% 15.4%
USMV 8.8% 12.2%
SPY 7.5% 18.8%

In the first half, all three factor funds grew faster than SPY. In the second half, all three grew slower. Test only the first half and every factor works; test only the second and none does.

In the second half SPY grew faster than all three factor funds:

QUAL (quality)MTUM (momentum)USMV (low volatility)SPY (the market)
Growth of $10,000, second half: QUAL (quality) $29,891, MTUM (momentum) $25,965, USMV (low volatility) $21,535, SPY (the market) $31,544$10k$20k$30k2020202120222023202420252026
  • QUAL (quality) $29,891
  • MTUM (momentum) $25,965
  • USMV (low volatility) $21,535
  • SPY (the market) $31,544

Second half: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 19 March 2020 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.

A second trap hides in the split itself. Here the halves divide in March 2020, in the middle of the Covid crash, so the first half ends deep inside the fall. Move the split by a single trading day and the first-half growth rates change noticeably. When a period starts or ends inside a crash, check nearby dates before trusting the number.

Step 5: Test each crash on its own

Factor funds are often sold as a way to fall less. Check that crash by crash: a fund can protect you in one kind of fall and not another. Max drawdown is the largest fall from a high to a later low (max drawdown explained).

QUAL (quality)MTUM (momentum)USMV (low volatility)SPY (the market)
Drawdown from the previous high, full period. Worst falls: QUAL (quality) 34.1%; MTUM (momentum) 34.1%; USMV (low volatility) 33.1%; SPY (the market) 33.7%-30%-20%-10%0%2014201620182020202220242026
  • QUAL (quality) worst fall 34.1% (19 February 2020 to 23 March 2020), longest time below a previous high 1.9 years
  • MTUM (momentum) worst fall 34.1% (19 February 2020 to 23 March 2020), longest time below a previous high 2.3 years
  • USMV (low volatility) worst fall 33.1% (14 February 2020 to 23 March 2020), longest time below a previous high 2.0 years
  • SPY (the market) worst fall 33.7% (19 February 2020 to 23 March 2020), longest time below a previous high 1.9 years

Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 18 July 2013 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.

Follow along: the two big falls in this history

Portfolio Max drawdown (the Covid crash, 2020) Return in 2022 Longest time under water
QUAL 34.1% −20.5% 1.9 years
MTUM 34.1% −18.3% 2.3 years
USMV 33.1% −9.4% 2.0 years
SPY 33.7% −18.2% 1.9 years

In the sudden Covid crash, every fund fell about as far as SPY, low volatility included. In the slower fall of 2022, USMV lost much less than SPY. Quality, often described as defensive, lost more than SPY in 2022.

The year-by-year bars show how often each fund was ahead or behind in a single calendar year:

QUAL (quality)MTUM (momentum)USMV (low volatility)SPY (the market)
Calendar-year returns, QUAL (quality) best +33.9% (2019), worst -20.5% (2022); MTUM (momentum) best +37.5% (2017), worst -18.3% (2022); USMV (low volatility) best +27.7% (2019), worst -9.4% (2022); SPY (the market) best +31.2% (2019), worst -18.2% (2022)-20%-10%0%+10%+20%+30%+40%201420162018202020222024
201420152016201720182019202020212022202320242025
QUAL (quality)+11.7%+5.4%+9.2%+22.3%−5.7%+33.9%+17.0%+26.9%−20.5%+30.9%+23.1%+12.7%
MTUM (momentum)+14.6%+8.9%+5.0%+37.5%−1.7%+27.3%+29.9%+13.4%−18.3%+9.1%+32.9%+22.1%
USMV (low volatility)+16.3%+5.4%+10.6%+18.9%+1.3%+27.7%+5.6%+20.8%−9.4%+10.3%+15.7%+7.6%
SPY (the market)+13.5%+1.2%+12.0%+21.7%−4.6%+31.2%+18.3%+28.7%−18.2%+26.2%+24.9%+17.7%

Full calendar years only. Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 18 July 2013 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.

Step 6: Look at the recent past, and the fund's rules

Factor funds change their holdings far more than a market fund, so their recent past can differ sharply from their long-run record. Over the last three years MTUM's growth gap to SPY was +1.3 points a year, but its worst fall in those three years was 30.0%, against 18.8% for SPY. When the stocks that led the market turn, a momentum fund holds a lot of them and can fall harder than the market.

Read the fund's own rules too. Two funds with the same factor in their name can define it differently, hold different numbers of stocks and re-pick at different times, so another momentum fund, such as SPMO, can give a different answer from MTUM over the same dates.

Step 7: Decide what you want the factor to do

Before you add a factor fund, write down the job you want it to do, then test for that job against your benchmark.

Before you trust a factor backtest

  • Same dates as a plain market fund
  • Every 5- and 10-year window
  • Each half of the history
  • Each crash on its own
  • The fund's own rules read
  • A reason the factor should keep working

What to aim for: a tilt whose reason you believe, whose worst stretch behind the market you could sit through, and whose result holds across windows, halves and crashes. A result that comes from one start date or one half of the history is not one you can trust.

What this example can't show: the test can only start in 2013, the first year all four funds have prices, so it has no 2008 crash and no dot-com crash. It uses one provider's definition of each factor. A little over a decade is short for a factor: academic studies use many decades, and show long droughts. To run the same checks on your own mix, follow how to backtest a portfolio.

Backtest your own portfolio Opens the builder with QUAL 100% against SPY (the market). Free account, no card.

Questions

What is factor investing?

It means building a portfolio around a trait that a group of stocks share, such as quality, momentum, low volatility, value or size, instead of owning every company by its market size. Factor funds follow fixed rules like an index fund, with a tilt towards that trait.

Do factor ETFs beat the market?

Not reliably. From 18 July 2013, QUAL grew 12.9% a year, MTUM 13.1% and USMV 10.3%, against 13.0% for SPY, and each spent long stretches behind it. Test a factor fund on every start date, not just one.

What is the quality factor?

Quality favours companies with high profits on their capital, steady earnings and little debt. In our test QUAL ended close to SPY over the whole period, but returned −20.5% in 2022 against −18.2% for SPY.

Do low volatility funds protect you in a crash?

Sometimes. In 2022 USMV returned −9.4% against −18.2% for SPY, but in the sudden Covid crash of 2020 its worst fall was 33.1%, about the same as SPY's 33.7%.

What is the difference between a single-factor and a multi-factor fund?

A single-factor fund gives you one tilt with all of its good and bad stretches; a multi-factor fund blends several, so their stretches can partly offset. Either way, compare it with a plain market fund over the same dates before you rely on it.

Build your index Opens the builder with QUAL 100% against SPY (the market). Free account, no card.

About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.