Myth
Does gold beat the S&P 500?
Gold beat the S&P 500 in only 13.1% of rolling 10-year periods since GLD launched, and over the whole period SPY returned 10.3% a year to gold's 9.4%, dividends included.
The myth, and why people believe it
Gold has a good story. It can't be printed, it has held value for thousands of years, and it tends to make headlines exactly when stocks are falling, which is when people are paying attention. Gold dealers publish comparisons that start in years when gold was cheap and stocks were expensive, and those charts travel well.
There's also a measurement trick. Most "gold beat stocks" charts compare the gold price with the S&P 500's price, leaving out dividends. Stocks pay them; gold doesn't. Over long periods reinvested dividends are a large part of what stocks return, so a price-only chart tilts the contest toward gold before it starts.
The test
How we tested this
We compared GLD, a fund that holds gold bullion, with SPY, an S&P 500 fund, both as total return so SPY's dividends are reinvested. The test runs from 18 November 2004, GLD's first day of trading, to 20 November 2026. We didn't pick start and end dates: we took every rolling 10-year period, starting each month, and checked which fund returned more, then did the same for 5-year periods. The rule for the verdict was set before we looked: Busted if gold won fewer than three in ten 10-year periods and also trailed over the whole stretch; Proven if it won more than seven in ten and led over the whole stretch; It depends otherwise.
The result
Over the full period, stocks finished ahead, but by less than most people think.
- GLD $72,751
- SPY 90 / GLD 10 $89,390
- SPY 80 / GLD 20 $91,155
- SPY $86,719
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 18 November 2004 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
$10,000 put into SPY when GLD launched grew to $86,719; the same amount in GLD grew to $72,751. That's 10.3% a year against 9.4%. Gold came closer than its reputation among stock investors suggests, but one start date is exactly what this test was built to avoid.
Gold won few 10-year periods, and all of them started in the years just before 2008.
GLD finished ahead of SPY in 13.1% of 145 rolling 10-year windows (window ends by month). The last window GLD won ended October 2016.
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 18 November 2004 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Across 145 rolling 10-year periods, gold finished ahead in 13.1%. Every one of its wins was a decade that started before the 2008 crash, and the last ended in October 2016; no 10-year period ending later went gold's way. Over shorter 5-year periods gold won more often, 28.3%, which is why recent headlines can say gold is winning while the long record says otherwise. The calendar-year scorecard is closer still: gold had the better year in 52.4% of full years. Gold wins plenty of years; it rarely wins decades.
The full test period is on Investor; the free plan replays the last 3 years.
Where the myth has a point
Gold held up in stock crashes, then had a long slump of its own.
- GLD worst fall 45.6% (22 August 2011 to 17 December 2015), longest time below a previous high 8.9 years
- SPY 90 / GLD 10 worst fall 49.4% (12 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 3.4 years
- SPY 80 / GLD 20 worst fall 43.4% (31 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 3.0 years
- SPY worst fall 55.2% (9 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 4.9 years
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 18 November 2004 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Gold's case was never mainly about long-run return; it's about moving differently from stocks when stocks fall, and here the data backs it. In 2008, the worst year for SPY in the period, SPY returned −36.8% while GLD returned +4.9%. In 2022 SPY returned −18.2% and GLD −0.8%.
But gold is not a calm asset. Its worst fall was 45.6%, from a peak in 2011 to a low in 2015, against SPY's 55.2% in 2008 and 2009. Gold also took far longer to get back: it spent 8.9 years below its 2011 high, against 4.9 years for SPY after 2007. Gold's protection worked in stock crashes, not in its own.
What it means for your portfolio
The question most investors face isn't gold or stocks. It's whether a slice of gold changes the ride. Over this period it did: SPY with a tenth in GLD, rebalanced once a year, returned 10.5% a year with a worst fall of 49.4%; with a fifth in GLD, 10.6% and 43.4%; SPY alone, 10.3% and 55.2%. Both mixes slightly out-returned SPY with shallower falls, because gold and stocks tended to drop at different times and yearly rebalancing sold whichever had run up to buy the other.
That's one period with one rebalancing rule, not a promise. A stretch dominated by gold's 2011 to 2015 slump would look worse for the mix. Test your own mix on your own dates before drawing a conclusion: the free backtest runs up to five holdings against SPY, and our methodology explains how every figure here is calculated. If you hold an S&P 500 fund, its holdings page shows what the stock side of this test owns.
Questions
Does gold outperform the S&P 500?
Over the long run, rarely. Since GLD launched, gold beat SPY in 13.1% of 10-year periods and trailed it over the whole period, dividends included.
Why do some charts show gold beating stocks?
Most compare the gold price with the S&P 500's price, leaving out dividends, and many start in a year when gold was cheap. A fair test uses total return and checks every start date, not one.
Does gold protect a portfolio in a crash?
In 2008 and 2022, the two worst years for stocks in the period, gold lost far less than SPY. It is not crash-proof itself: its own worst fall, after 2011, was 45.6% and took years to recover.
Why test GLD instead of the gold price?
GLD is a fund you can actually buy, so its returns include its costs, the same way SPY's do. That makes the comparison like for like.
Can I run this test on my own portfolio?
Yes. Clone the example, change the weights or add your own holdings (up to five on the free plan), and compare against SPY. The free plan covers the last 3 years; the full period is on Investor.
About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.