Guide
Equal weight vs market cap: the S&P 500 tested both ways
An equal-weight S&P 500 fund gives every company in the index the same slice of your money, while a market-cap fund gives the biggest companies the biggest slices. From 30 April 2003 to 20 November 2026, the equal-weight fund RSP and SPY grew at almost the same yearly rate (11.0% and 10.9%), yet RSP beat SPY in only 46.3% of 10-year windows and fell further at its worst.
Two ways to weight the same companies
An index is a list of companies plus a rule for how much of each to hold. The rule is called the weighting. Two funds can own exactly the same companies and still behave very differently because of it.
Market-cap weight (often shortened to cap weight) sizes each company by its market capitalisation: its share price times the number of shares, which is what the whole company is worth on the stock market. The largest companies get the largest slices, and the fund never has to trade to stay that way, because a company whose price rises grows inside the fund on its own. SPY, VOO and most index funds work like this.
Equal weight gives each company the same slice, whatever its size. Prices move every day, so the slices drift apart, and the fund has to rebalance: on a fixed schedule it sells some of what has grown and buys what has shrunk, to bring every slice back to equal. RSP tracks the equal-weight version of the S&P 500, and some sector funds such as the biotech fund XBI use equal weight too.
A third rule you will meet is inverse volatility weight. Volatility measures how much a price swings, as a yearly percentage; inverse volatility gives calmer stocks bigger slices and jumpier ones smaller slices. It sits between the other two: it ignores company size like equal weight, but it is not neutral, because it leans towards steady sectors.
Two ways to weight the same index
Market-cap weight
- Bigger companies get bigger slices
- Winners grow on their own
- No trading needed to stay on target
- A few giants can drive the result
Equal weight
- Every company gets the same slice
- Rebalanced on a fixed schedule
- Sells recent winners, buys recent losers
- More weight in smaller companies
The follow-along example
We compare the two real S&P 500 funds, RSP (equal weight) and SPY (cap weight), with dividends reinvested, from the first day both have a full history. To see the mechanism up close, we also build a small index of five well-known stocks, Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), Procter & Gamble (PG), Coca-Cola (KO), PepsiCo (PEP) and McDonald's (MCD), and run it two ways.
Follow along: the four baskets
Basket What it holds Rule RSP Equal-weight S&P 500 fund Held as one fund SPY Cap-weight S&P 500 fund Held as one fund; our benchmark Five stocks, rebalanced JNJ, PG, KO, PEP, MCD 20% each, reset to 20% every quarter Five stocks, never rebalanced JNJ, PG, KO, PEP, MCD 20% each on day one, then left alone The benchmark is the yardstick the others are measured against. The never-rebalanced basket is the key to this guide: left alone, an equal start slowly turns into a cap-weight portfolio, because each stock's slice grows with its price.
How we tested this
Step 1: Run the whole history
Start with $10,000 in each fund and read the end values. Over this period the two ways of weighting the S&P 500 ended up almost level.
- RSP (equal weight) $116,365
- Five stocks, 20% each, rebalanced quarterly $115,641
- Five stocks, 20% each, never rebalanced $123,833
- SPY (market cap weight) $115,030
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced quarterly, single funds held throughout, 30 April 2003 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Follow along: $10,000 in each fund
Fund End value CAGR Gap vs SPY RSP, equal weight $116,365 11.0% +0.1 points SPY, cap weight $115,030 10.9% CAGR, the compound annual growth rate, is the steady yearly rate that turns the start value into the end value. A gap this small is noise next to how far the two lines moved apart along the way.
The trap here is stopping at the end value. A near tie over the whole period hides two long stretches in which one fund clearly led.
Step 2: Split the history in two
Cut the period in half and run the same comparison on each half. This is the quickest way to see how much a result depends on the dates you picked.
Follow along: two halves, two different winners
Fund CAGR, first half CAGR, second half CAGR, last 3 years RSP 11.7% 10.3% 14.2% SPY 9.2% 12.7% 16.3% Equal weight led clearly in the first half, which ran from 2003 to early 2015 and holds the 2008 crash. Cap weight led in the second half, when the largest companies grew much faster than the average one, and the gap was widest in the last three years.
In the second half SPY pulled away as the biggest companies kept growing.
- RSP (equal weight) $31,609
- Five stocks, 20% each, rebalanced quarterly $32,864
- Five stocks, 20% each, never rebalanced $33,769
- SPY (market cap weight) $40,912
Second half: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced quarterly, single funds held throughout, 9 February 2015 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Step 3: Check every start date
The full test is every window: take every 10-year stretch in the history and ask which fund grew faster over it.
RSP (equal weight) finished ahead of SPY (market cap weight) in 46.3% of 164 rolling 10-year windows (window ends by month). The last window RSP (equal weight) won ended July 2019.
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced quarterly, single funds held throughout, 30 April 2003 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Follow along: how often equal weight beat cap weight
Window length Windows tested RSP ahead Smallest gap Largest gap Last window RSP won ended 5 years 224 44.6% −5.6 points +5.5 points February 2023 10 years 164 46.3% −3.8 points +2.7 points July 2019 20 years 44 18.2% −1.4 points +0.8 points December 2023 The gaps are yearly growth differences in percentage points. Over 5 years the two funds were sometimes several points a year apart in either direction, so the choice of weighting mattered a lot to anyone holding for that long, even though neither rule won consistently.
What to aim for when you test a weighting rule: a win share well above half over long windows, and a gap that is not driven by one stretch of years. Neither fund passes that bar here, which is the honest answer to "which is better".
Step 4: Read the risk side, not just the return
Maximum drawdown is the biggest fall from a high to the following low. "Under water" means below a previous high; the longest time under water is the longest wait to get back.
Follow along: the risk side
Fund Volatility Maximum drawdown Longest time under water 2008 2022 RSP 19.7% 59.9% 3.6 years −40.1% −11.6% SPY 18.5% 55.2% 4.9 years −36.8% −18.2% Equal weight is often sold as the safer, more diversified choice. In this test it swung more day to day and fell further in 2008. Yet it climbed back to its old high sooner than SPY, and in 2022 it fell much less, which means the largest companies, the ones SPY holds most of, fell harder than the average company that year.
Spreading money evenly across companies is not the same as lowering risk. Equal weight holds more of the index's smaller companies, and in 2008 that meant a deeper fall.
- RSP (equal weight) worst fall 59.9% (19 July 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 3.6 years
- Five stocks, 20% each, rebalanced quarterly worst fall 31.5% (13 December 2007 to 5 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 2.3 years
- Five stocks, 20% each, never rebalanced worst fall 32.6% (14 February 2020 to 23 March 2020), longest time below a previous high 1.5 years
- SPY (market cap weight) worst fall 55.2% (9 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 4.9 years
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced quarterly, single funds held throughout, 30 April 2003 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Step 5: Look at the years one by one
Calendar years show when each rule helps. RSP finished ahead of SPY in 45.5% of full calendar years, and the losses came in runs: SPY was ahead every year from 2017 to 2020, and again from 2023 to 2025.
| 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RSP (equal weight) | +16.5% | +7.4% | +15.5% | +0.9% | −40.1% | +44.6% | +21.4% | −0.7% | +17.2% | +35.5% | +14.1% | −2.7% | +14.5% | +18.5% | −7.8% | +28.9% | +12.7% | +29.4% | −11.6% | +13.7% | +12.8% | +11.2% |
| Five stocks, 20% each, rebalanced quarterly | +13.3% | +5.5% | +18.3% | +22.0% | −12.8% | +12.4% | +13.2% | +13.1% | +4.2% | +22.7% | +11.2% | +6.7% | +7.9% | +22.7% | +1.4% | +24.0% | +10.4% | +18.4% | +3.9% | −0.3% | +2.9% | +10.6% |
| Five stocks, 20% each, never rebalanced | +13.3% | +5.6% | +19.9% | +24.7% | −8.8% | +9.5% | +17.1% | +19.7% | −1.1% | +19.4% | +7.5% | +13.2% | +7.0% | +30.3% | +2.8% | +19.4% | +10.6% | +22.2% | +2.3% | +5.9% | +1.4% | +8.5% |
| SPY (market cap weight) | +10.7% | +4.8% | +15.8% | +5.1% | −36.8% | +26.4% | +15.1% | +1.9% | +16.0% | +32.3% | +13.5% | +1.2% | +12.0% | +21.7% | −4.6% | +31.2% | +18.3% | +28.7% | −18.2% | +26.2% | +24.9% | +17.7% |
Full calendar years only. Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced quarterly, single funds held throughout, 30 April 2003 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Its best year was 2009 and its worst 2008, the same worst year as SPY. Look for runs like these when you test a weighting: a rule that wins in clusters can leave you behind for many years in a row before it pays.
Step 6: See the mechanism with five stocks
The five-stock baskets show what weighting really does, without the noise of hundreds of companies. Both start at 20% each. One is reset to 20% every quarter, like an equal-weight fund. The other is never touched, so each stock's slice grows or shrinks with its price, which is exactly how cap weight behaves.
Follow along: the same five stocks, two rules
Basket End value CAGR Volatility Maximum drawdown CAGR, last 3 years Rebalanced every quarter $115,641 10.9% 14.4% 31.5% 11.1% Never rebalanced $123,833 11.3% 15.0% 32.6% 6.9% Left alone, the basket stopped being equal: McDonald's grew into by far the largest slice. That let the winner run, and the never-rebalanced basket ended with more money. It also swung a little more and fell a little further at its worst, and in the last three years, with so much riding on one stock, it fell behind the rebalanced version.
| Basket | Yearly return | Volatility | Sharpe | Worst drop | $10,000 became |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RSP (equal weight) | 11.0% | 19.7% | 0.63 | 59.9% | $116,365 |
| Five stocks, 20% each, rebalanced quarterly | 10.9% | 14.4% | 0.80 | 31.5% | $115,641 |
| Five stocks, 20% each, never rebalanced | 11.3% | 15.0% | 0.79 | 32.6% | $123,833 |
| SPY (market cap weight) | 10.9% | 18.5% | 0.65 | 55.2% | $115,030 |
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced quarterly, single funds held throughout, 30 April 2003 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns. Sharpe uses a 0% risk-free rate.
This is the core trade-off, and it is the trap most people miss. Rebalancing is not free extra return: it trims your winners, which costs you when a winner keeps winning and helps you when leadership changes. Cap weight is the opposite bet. Neither rule is better in general; each is a bet on whether today's leaders keep leading.
Step 7: Decide what you want the weighting to do
Choose the rule for the job, then test it on your own holdings over every window, not one. If you want a mix that needs no weighting decisions at all, the lazy portfolios guide tests four fixed recipes.
Before you choose a weighting
- Test the whole history, then each half
- Check every 5 and 10-year window, not one
- Compare the worst fall and the time under water
- Look at the bad years one by one
- Know what the rule is betting on
- Cap weight if you want the market as it is, with little trading, and you accept that a few giants can drive most of the result.
- Equal weight if you want each company to count the same and you accept long runs behind the market, deeper falls in broad crashes and more trading inside the fund.
- Inverse volatility if you want a smoother ride from a small set of stocks and you accept a tilt towards calm sectors. This example can't show how it would have done, so test it on your own list before relying on it.
What this example can't show: one period of US history, one equal-weight fund, and five stocks chosen because readers know them. Run your own holdings with each rule before you decide; our guides on how to backtest a portfolio and the CAGR formula show how to read the results.
Questions
Is the equal-weight S&P 500 better than the regular S&P 500?
Not in general. In our test RSP and SPY ended almost level over the whole period, equal weight led in the first half and cap weight in the second, and RSP beat SPY in 46.3% of 10-year windows. Which one looks better depends mostly on the dates you pick.
Why has the equal-weight S&P 500 lagged in recent years?
Because the largest companies grew much faster than the average one. A cap-weight fund holds most of its money in those companies; an equal-weight fund holds the same slice of each and trims winners when it rebalances. Over the last 3 years RSP grew at 14.2% a year against 16.3% for SPY.
Is RSP riskier than SPY?
By most measures in our test, yes. It swung more (19.7% against 18.5%) and its worst fall was deeper (59.9% against 55.2%). It did fall less in 2022 and got back to its old high sooner after 2008.
Does rebalancing to equal weight add return?
Not by itself. In our five-stock example the never-rebalanced basket ended with more money because one stock kept winning. Rebalancing helps when leadership changes and costs you when the same winners keep leading.
What is inverse volatility weighting?
A rule that gives calmer stocks bigger slices and jumpier stocks smaller ones, based on how much each price has swung. It aims for a smoother ride, but it tilts the portfolio towards steady sectors, so test it on your own holdings before using it.
About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.