Myth
Are dividend stocks safer in a crash?
No, not in the crashes that hit the whole market: in the 2008 crisis VYM fell 57.0% from its high and DVY 62.6%, against 55.2% for SPY, and both also fell further than SPY in the 2020 crash. They held up far better in 2022, which is where the myth comes from.
The myth, and why people believe it
Dividend stocks sound like the sensible end of the market: mature companies, steady profits, cash paid out every quarter. The payments keep arriving when prices fall, which feels like a cushion, and the 2022 sell-off, when dividend funds barely moved while the S&P 500 dropped, is still fresh. So the idea took hold that a dividend fund is a safer way to own stocks when a crash comes.
Two things make the idea easy to believe. Calendar-year returns, the figures most people see, can hide how far a fund fell inside the year. And "safer" usually gets judged on the most recent crash, not all of them.
The test
How we tested this
We compared two of the largest dividend funds with the S&P 500: VYM, which holds US stocks with above-average dividend yields, and DVY, which picks fewer, higher-yielding stocks. SPY stands in for the market. All three are total return, so dividends are reinvested, and the test runs from 16 November 2006, VYM's first day, to 20 November 2026. That covers three very different crashes: the 2008 financial crisis, the Covid crash of 2020 and the 2022 rate shock.
Our measure of a crash is the maximum drawdown: the biggest fall from a high to the following low, in percent. We split the history into two halves, one holding 2008 and one holding 2020 and 2022, and took each fund's worst fall in each. The rule was set before we looked at the dividend funds: Proven if both fell at least 2 points less than SPY in both halves; Busted if neither did in either half; It depends otherwise.
The result
In the two worst crashes, both dividend funds fell further than the S&P 500.
- VYM worst fall 57.0% (9 October 2007 to 5 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 4.4 years
- DVY worst fall 62.6% (22 May 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 5.7 years
- SPY worst fall 55.2% (9 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 4.9 years
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 16 November 2006 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
| Worst fall | First half (2008 crisis) | Second half (2020 and 2022) |
|---|---|---|
| VYM | 57.0% | 35.2% |
| DVY | 62.6% | 41.6% |
| SPY | 55.2% | 33.7% |
DVY, the higher-yielding fund, fell furthest both times. The 2020 crash also took the dividend funds longer to recover from: SPY was back at its old high in August 2020, VYM only at the end of the year and DVY in February 2021. Over the whole period both trailed SPY, at 9.0% and 7.9% a year against 10.3%.
Where the myth has a point
The year-by-year picture is kinder, and it explains why the myth survives.
| 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| VYM | +1.4% | −31.9% | +17.2% | +14.2% | +10.6% | +12.7% | +30.1% | +13.5% | +0.3% | +17.0% | +16.4% | −5.9% | +24.1% | +1.1% | +26.2% | −0.4% | +6.6% | +17.6% | +15.4% |
| DVY | −5.7% | −32.9% | +11.2% | +17.8% | +11.8% | +10.5% | +28.9% | +14.9% | −2.1% | +21.6% | +14.8% | −6.4% | +22.6% | −4.9% | +31.7% | +1.8% | +1.1% | +16.2% | +11.6% |
| SPY | +5.1% | −36.8% | +26.4% | +15.1% | +1.9% | +16.0% | +32.3% | +13.5% | +1.2% | +12.0% | +21.7% | −4.6% | +31.2% | +18.3% | +28.7% | −18.2% | +26.2% | +24.9% | +17.7% |
Full calendar years only. Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 16 November 2006 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
In 2022 the dividend funds did what their fans say: VYM returned −0.4% and DVY +1.8%, against −18.2% for SPY. That sell-off hit expensive growth stocks hardest, and those pay little or no dividend, so dividend funds hold few of them. Even 2008 looks better on a calendar: VYM returned −31.9% and DVY −32.9%, against −36.8% for SPY. But the crash didn't follow the calendar. DVY's high came in May 2007, months before SPY's, and it returned −5.7% that year against +5.1% for SPY; both dividend funds then kept falling into March 2009. Counted from high to low, the falls were deeper.
There's one more point in VYM's favour: after 2008 it spent 4.4 years below its previous high, a little less than SPY's 4.9 years. DVY took 5.7 years.
So dividend funds protected investors in one kind of crash, a sell-off in expensive growth stocks, and not in the other two. "Safer" depends on which crash comes next, and nobody knows that in advance.
What it means for your portfolio
A dividend fund is still a stock fund, and in a broad crash it can fall as far as the market or further. If what you want is a smaller worst fall, the lever that has worked is holding less in stocks, not choosing different ones. Our Sharpe vs Sortino vs Calmar guide shows how to weigh a smaller fall against a lower return, and how to backtest a portfolio shows how to test a mix through more than one kind of bad year.
SCHD, the most talked-about dividend fund, isn't in this test: it launched in 2011, so it can't show 2008. Its record since then is on the SCHD page and in SCHD vs VOO; for these two funds side by side, see SCHD vs VYM and the VYM page.
Questions
Do dividend stocks fall less in a crash?
Not in the broad crashes tested here. In 2008 and 2020 both VYM and DVY fell further from their highs than SPY. They fell far less in 2022, a sell-off led by expensive growth stocks.
Do dividends keep being paid in a crash?
Many companies keep paying, but some cut, and a payment doesn't stop the price falling. With dividends reinvested, as in this test, the funds still had deeper worst falls than SPY in 2008 and 2020.
Is SCHD safer in a crash?
This test can't say for 2008, because SCHD launched in 2011. Its record since then is on our SCHD pages; like any stock fund, it fell sharply in the 2020 crash.
What actually reduces how far a portfolio falls?
Holding less in stocks has been the main lever: adding bonds or cash shrinks the worst fall, at the cost of lower long-run growth. Test a mix through more than one kind of crash before relying on it.
About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.