Myth

"Time in the market beats timing the market": what missing the best days really costs

It depends. Missing only SPY's ten best days since 29 January 1993 cut its yearly growth from 10.4% to 7.7%, but those days sat right next to the worst ones, and missing the ten best and the ten worst together left 10.6%.

VerdictIt dependsChecked against the data on 20 November 2026

The myth, and why people believe it

The claim appears in almost every fund company's case against market timing: stay out of the market for a handful of its best days and decades of growth disappear. Market timing means moving in and out of stocks to dodge falls; time in the market means staying invested through them. The numbers behind the claim are real. What they usually leave out is when those best days happen.

How we tested it

How we tested this

DataDaily prices for SPY adjusted for splits and dividends (total return), from EODHD; the 200-day average uses plain closing prices.
Period10 April 2007 to 20 November 2026, the longest period every holding has prices for
BasketsSPY 60 / BND 40: BND 40%, SPY 60%, rebalanced yearly; SPY: SPY 100%, held throughout (benchmark)
StudySPY daily total returns (dividends reinvested), 29 January 1993 to 20 November 2026. Buy and hold against the same days with the 10 and 20 best, worst, or best and worst days' returns replaced by 0%, as if in cash earning nothing; days ranked by daily return over the whole period. A best day is near a worst one when it came within 10 trading days of one of the 20 worst days; below the average means the previous close was under its 200-day average of plain closing prices. No costs or taxes.
How we testedEach scenario replaces the chosen days' returns with 0%, as if in cash at no interest, and compounds the rest. Best and worst days are ranked by daily total return over the whole period. Near means within ten trading days of one of the twenty worst days. Proven if missing the ten best costs at least two points a year and missing the ten best and ten worst still trails holding; Busted if missing the ten best costs under one point; It depends otherwise.
Not includedTrading costs, taxes and interest on cash; missing a day here means missing exactly that day, not a stretch around it.
Verdict rule, set before lookingBusted if the yearly return held minus the yearly return with the 10 best days missed is below 1.0 points; Proven if the yearly return held minus the yearly return with the 10 best days missed is at least 2.0 points and the yearly return with the 10 best and 10 worst days missed minus held is at most zero; It depends otherwise.

We took SPY, an S&P 500 fund, with dividends reinvested, every trading day from 29 January 1993 to 20 November 2026, 8,511 days in all. CAGR, the compound annual growth rate, is the steady yearly rate that turns the start value into the end value. We then replaced the best days with a flat day, as if you had been in cash earning nothing, and did the same with the worst days, and with both.

Before running it we set the line. The myth is proven if missing the ten best days costs at least two points a year and missing the ten best and ten worst together still leaves you behind holding. It is busted if missing the ten best costs less than one point a year. Anything in between is It depends.

The result

Missing the best days alone is as costly as the myth says.

Yearly return of SPY, 29 January 1993 to 20 November 2026: held every day 10.4%; missed the 10 best days 7.7%; missed the 10 best and 10 worst 10.6%; missed the 20 best days 6.0%; missed the 20 best and 20 worst 10.7%0%2%4%6%8%10%12%14%16%Held every dayHeld every day: 10.4% a year, $10,000 became $286,73710.4%Missed the 10 best daysMissed the 10 best days: 7.7% a year, $10,000 became $124,4207.7%Missed the 20 best daysMissed the 20 best days: 6.0% a year, $10,000 became $71,8956.0%Missed the 10 best and 10 worstMissed the 10 best and 10 worst: 10.6% a year, $10,000 became $298,33010.6%Missed the 20 best and 20 worstMissed the 20 best and 20 worst: 10.7% a year, $10,000 became $307,42310.7%Missed the 10 worst daysMissed the 10 worst days: 13.3% a year, $10,000 became $687,52713.3%Missed the 20 worst daysMissed the 20 worst days: 15.3% a year, $10,000 became $1,226,08915.3%
  • 8,511 trading days. Held every day: 10.4% a year, $10,000 became $286,737
  • Without the 10 best days: 7.7% a year, 2.7 points less; without the 10 best and 10 worst: 10.6% (+0.13 points against holding)
  • Best days near the worst: 8 of the 10 best came within 10 trading days of one of the 20 worst
  • Best days in falling markets: 18 of the 20 best came with the previous close below its 200-day average, a state on 24.9% of all days
ScenarioYearly return (CAGR)$10,000 became
Held every day10.4%$286,737
Missed the 10 best days7.7%$124,420
Missed the 20 best days6.0%$71,895
Missed the 10 best and 10 worst10.6%$298,330
Missed the 20 best and 20 worst10.7%$307,423
Missed the 10 worst days13.3%$687,527
Missed the 20 worst days15.3%$1,226,089

A missed day earns 0%, as if in cash at no interest. No costs or taxes. Indices Lab study on SPY, dividends reinvested, 29 January 1993 to 20 November 2026. Data: EODHD. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.

Ten days out of 8,511 cost 2.7 points a year. That passes the first half of our line.

The second half fails, because the best days and the worst days arrive together. Of the ten best days, 8 came within two weeks (ten trading days) of one of the twenty worst. Most fell in two short storms, late 2008 and March to April 2020, often within a few trading days of a crash day. The best day of all, 13 October 2008 (+14.5%), came two trading days before the second-worst, 15 October 2008 (−9.8%).

20 best days20 worst days
The 20 best and 20 worst days of SPY on a time axis. Best days by year: 2008: 6, 2020: 5, 1998: 2, 2009: 2, 1997: 1, 2000: 1, 2002: 1, 2022: 1, 2025: 1. Worst days by year: 2008: 10, 2020: 4, 1997: 1, 1998: 1, 2001: 1, 2009: 1, 2011: 1, 2025: 11995200020052010201520202025+15%−15%Best day 1: 13 October 2008, +14.5%Best day 2: 28 October 2008, +11.7%Best day 3: 9 April 2025, +10.5%Best day 4: 24 March 2020, +9.1%Best day 5: 13 March 2020, +8.5%Best day 6: 23 March 2009, +7.2%Best day 7: 24 November 2008, +6.9%Best day 8: 6 April 2020, +6.7%Best day 9: 13 November 2008, +6.2%Best day 10: 20 October 2008, +6.0%Best day 11: 24 July 2002, +6.0%Best day 12: 10 March 2009, +6.0%Best day 13: 26 March 2020, +5.8%Best day 14: 7 January 2000, +5.8%Best day 15: 28 October 1997, +5.8%Best day 16: 10 November 2022, +5.5%Best day 17: 17 March 2020, +5.4%Best day 18: 21 November 2008, +5.4%Best day 19: 15 October 1998, +5.4%Best day 20: 8 September 1998, +5.4%Worst day 1: 16 March 2020, −10.9%Worst day 2: 15 October 2008, −9.8%Worst day 3: 12 March 2020, −9.6%Worst day 4: 1 December 2008, −8.9%Worst day 5: 29 September 2008, −7.8%Worst day 6: 9 March 2020, −7.8%Worst day 7: 20 November 2008, −7.4%Worst day 8: 27 October 1997, −7.2%Worst day 9: 31 August 1998, −7.1%Worst day 10: 9 October 2008, −7.0%Worst day 11: 8 August 2011, −6.5%Worst day 12: 19 November 2008, −6.4%Worst day 13: 4 April 2025, −5.9%Worst day 14: 11 June 2020, −5.8%Worst day 15: 6 November 2008, −5.5%Worst day 16: 22 October 2008, −5.4%Worst day 17: 20 January 2009, −5.3%Worst day 18: 17 September 2001, −5.2%Worst day 19: 6 October 2008, −5.1%Worst day 20: 24 October 2008, −5.1%
  • Best 20 by year: 2008: 6, 2020: 5, 1998: 2, 2009: 2, 1997: 1, 2000: 1, 2002: 1, 2022: 1, 2025: 1
  • Worst 20 by year: 2008: 10, 2020: 4, 1997: 1, 1998: 1, 2001: 1, 2009: 1, 2011: 1, 2025: 1
RankBest dayWorst day
113 October 2008+14.5%16 March 2020−10.9%
228 October 2008+11.7%15 October 2008−9.8%
39 April 2025+10.5%12 March 2020−9.6%
424 March 2020+9.1%1 December 2008−8.9%
513 March 2020+8.5%29 September 2008−7.8%
623 March 2009+7.2%9 March 2020−7.8%
724 November 2008+6.9%20 November 2008−7.4%
86 April 2020+6.7%27 October 1997−7.2%
913 November 2008+6.2%31 August 1998−7.1%
1020 October 2008+6.0%9 October 2008−7.0%
1124 July 2002+6.0%8 August 2011−6.5%
1210 March 2009+6.0%19 November 2008−6.4%
1326 March 2020+5.8%4 April 2025−5.9%
147 January 2000+5.8%11 June 2020−5.8%
1528 October 1997+5.8%6 November 2008−5.5%
1610 November 2022+5.5%22 October 2008−5.4%
1717 March 2020+5.4%20 January 2009−5.3%
1821 November 2008+5.4%17 September 2001−5.2%
1915 October 1998+5.4%6 October 2008−5.1%
208 September 1998+5.4%24 October 2008−5.1%

Days ranked by daily total return. Indices Lab study on SPY, dividends reinvested, 29 January 1993 to 20 November 2026. Data: EODHD. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.

So a timer who sat out the best days was almost always out because of the worst ones around them. Missing both sets left yearly growth at 10.6%, a gap of +0.13 points against holding: not ruined at all. Missing only the worst days looks even better, 13.3% a year, but that is as unrealistic as missing only the best: nobody knows in advance which days they will be.

Where the myth has a point

The trouble is that nobody chooses which days to miss. In our test, 18 of the twenty best days came when SPY had closed below its 200-day average the day before. The 200-day average is the mean closing price of the past 200 trading days, and a close below it is a common sign of a falling market. SPY was in that state on only 24.9% of all days.

Those are exactly the weeks when fear makes people sell. Anyone who gets out in a crash and waits for calm before buying back is very likely to miss the rebound days after already taking the losses. That is the real cost the myth points at, and it is large.

Our golden cross test shows the same thing from the other side: a simple rule that stepped out of SPY in downtrends missed most of the best days and still trailed holding.

Clone this example Opens the builder with BND 40%, SPY 60% against SPY. Free account, no card.

What it means for your portfolio

The useful lesson is not "never miss a day". It is that the best and worst days come in the same short storms, so a plan you can hold through those storms matters more than any timing call. If a crash would push you to sell, one common answer is a mix that falls less, such as some bonds next to stocks, chosen before the storm rather than during it. Test how your own mix behaved in 2008 and 2020, and how long it took to recover, before you need to know.

Our guide on how to backtest a portfolio shows how, max drawdown explained covers how far and how long a mix fell, and the buy-the-dip test looks at the opposite habit of waiting for a fall before investing.

Backtest your own portfolio Opens the builder with BND 40%, SPY 60% against SPY. Free account, no card.

Questions

Is it true that missing the ten best days cuts your returns in half?

For the end value, it did more than that. In our SPY test, $10,000 held since 29 January 1993 grew to $286,737; missing the ten best days left $124,420. But that assumes you missed only the best days and none of the worst around them.

Do the best days come right after the worst days?

Very often. Of SPY's ten best days since 29 January 1993, 8 came within ten trading days of one of its twenty worst, mostly in late 2008 and March to April 2020.

Is time in the market better than timing the market?

In this test, the cost of timing came from selling in a fall and missing the rebound. Timing needs two right calls, when to get out and when to get back in, and the rebound days came when getting back in felt hardest.

What if you missed the worst days instead?

Missing only the ten worst days would have lifted yearly growth to 13.3%, but that is as unrealistic as missing only the best: no one knows in advance which days they will be.

Build your index Opens the builder with BND 40%, SPY 60% against SPY. Free account, no card.

About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.