Myth
Does buying the dip always pay?
Rarely: waiting for a ten percent dip before putting cash into SPY beat investing straight away in only 28.0% of start months since 1993, and the bigger the dip you wait for, the more it cost on average. The verdict is It depends rather than Busted because in many months the market was already in a dip, so waiting and investing at once came out the same.
The myth, and why people believe it
"Buy low" is the oldest advice in investing, and every crash seems to prove it: anyone who bought in March 2009 or March 2020 looks like a genius. So when markets are high, waiting for a pullback feels prudent. The catch is that you only remember the dips that came. You don't see the months you sat in cash while the market climbed, and the dip, when it finally came, often started from a higher price than the one you passed up.
The test
How we tested this
We took SPY, the S&P 500 in one fund, with dividends reinvested, from 29 January 1993 to 20 November 2026. On the first trading day of every month, one investor puts $10,000 in straight away. A second holds the same $10,000 in cash until SPY closes five, ten or twenty percent below its all-time high, then buys and holds. If SPY is already that far down, both buy the same day. We compared what each had five years later, across all 346 start months with a full five years, and checked the answer again at ten years. The verdict rule was set before we looked at the results.
The result
Waiting for a dip won in under a third of start months, whichever dip you waited for:
- 5% dip, 5 years: waiting won 28.9%, same day 46.2%, lost 24.9% (the dip never came 0.0%)
- 10% dip, 5 years: waiting won 28.0%, same day 31.2%, lost 40.8% (the dip never came 0.0%)
- 20% dip, 5 years: waiting won 32.9%, same day 19.1%, lost 48.0% (the dip never came 22.8%)
- 5% dip, 10 years: waiting won 28.3%, same day 51.0%, lost 20.6% (the dip never came 0.0%)
- 10% dip, 10 years: waiting won 26.2%, same day 36.7%, lost 37.1% (the dip never came 0.0%)
- 20% dip, 10 years: waiting won 27.3%, same day 22.7%, lost 50.0% (the dip never came 0.0%)
| Start | Invest now | Wait for 5% | Wait for 10% | Wait for 20% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 February 1993 | $24,771 | $23,591bought 29 March 1994 | $13,554bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 March 1993 | $26,469 | $25,226bought 29 March 1994 | $14,493bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 April 1993 | $27,389 | $26,671bought 29 March 1994 | $15,323bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 3 May 1993 | $28,277 | $27,096bought 29 March 1994 | $15,567bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 June 1993 | $26,698 | $26,359bought 29 March 1994 | $15,144bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 July 1993 | $28,277 | $27,672bought 29 March 1994 | $15,899bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 2 August 1993 | $27,556 | $26,986bought 29 March 1994 | $15,504bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 September 1993 | $23,855 | $24,157bought 29 March 1994 | $13,879bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 October 1993 | $23,669 | $23,939bought 29 March 1994 | $13,754bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 November 1993 | $25,893 | $26,649bought 29 March 1994 | $15,311bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 December 1993 | $28,023 | $28,497bought 29 March 1994 | $16,372bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 3 January 1994 | $29,255 | $29,974bought 29 March 1994 | $17,221bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 February 1994 | $29,166 | $30,847bought 29 March 1994 | $17,723bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 March 1994 | $29,297 | $30,118bought 29 March 1994 | $17,304bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 4 April 1994 | $32,368 | $32,368same day | $18,107bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 2 May 1994 | $32,267 | $32,267same day | $18,654bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 June 1994 | $30,982 | $31,407bought 21 June 1994 | $18,164bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 July 1994 | $33,912 | $33,912same day | $19,382bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 August 1994 | $31,510 | $32,102bought 22 November 1994 | $18,640bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 September 1994 | $30,814 | $32,329bought 22 November 1994 | $18,772bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 3 October 1994 | $30,436 | $31,155bought 22 November 1994 | $18,090bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 November 1994 | $31,507 | $32,875bought 22 November 1994 | $19,089bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 December 1994 | $33,943 | $33,943same day | $19,771bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 3 January 1995 | $34,478 | $24,390bought 15 July 1996 | $20,529bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 February 1995 | $32,491 | $23,635bought 15 July 1996 | $19,894bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 March 1995 | $30,850 | $23,216bought 15 July 1996 | $19,541bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 3 April 1995 | $32,582 | $25,429bought 15 July 1996 | $21,404bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 May 1995 | $30,930 | $24,725bought 15 July 1996 | $20,811bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 June 1995 | $29,392 | $24,431bought 15 July 1996 | $20,564bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 3 July 1995 | $29,083 | $24,820bought 15 July 1996 | $20,891bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 August 1995 | $27,674 | $24,246bought 15 July 1996 | $20,408bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 September 1995 | $29,002 | $25,678bought 15 July 1996 | $21,614bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 2 October 1995 | $26,583 | $24,302bought 15 July 1996 | $20,456bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 November 1995 | $26,063 | $24,070bought 15 July 1996 | $20,260bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 December 1995 | $23,314 | $22,338bought 15 July 1996 | $18,802bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 2 January 1996 | $22,226 | $21,829bought 15 July 1996 | $18,374bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 February 1996 | $23,141 | $23,375bought 15 July 1996 | $19,675bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 March 1996 | $20,588 | $21,116bought 15 July 1996 | $17,773bought 11 April 1997 | $10,000never |
| 1 April 1996 | $19,086 | $19,828bought 15 July 1996 | $16,690bought 11 April 1997 | $9,909bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 May 1996 | $20,751 | $21,589bought 15 July 1996 | $18,172bought 11 April 1997 | $10,789bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 June 1996 | $20,226 | $21,534bought 15 July 1996 | $18,126bought 11 April 1997 | $10,761bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 July 1996 | $19,339 | $20,892bought 15 July 1996 | $17,585bought 11 April 1997 | $10,440bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 August 1996 | $20,010 | $16,690bought 27 March 1997 | $17,515bought 11 April 1997 | $10,399bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 September 1996 | $18,537 | $15,602bought 27 March 1997 | $16,373bought 11 April 1997 | $9,721bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 October 1996 | $16,112 | $14,305bought 27 March 1997 | $15,012bought 11 April 1997 | $8,913bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 November 1996 | $16,389 | $14,887bought 27 March 1997 | $15,622bought 11 April 1997 | $9,275bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 December 1996 | $15,991 | $15,647bought 27 March 1997 | $16,420bought 11 April 1997 | $9,749bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 January 1997 | $16,606 | $15,905bought 27 March 1997 | $16,690bought 11 April 1997 | $9,909bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 February 1997 | $15,243 | $15,508bought 27 March 1997 | $16,274bought 11 April 1997 | $9,662bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 March 1997 | $15,188 | $15,658bought 27 March 1997 | $16,432bought 11 April 1997 | $9,756bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 April 1997 | $16,055 | $16,055same day | $16,599bought 11 April 1997 | $9,855bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 May 1997 | $14,508 | $12,877bought 15 August 1997 | $13,212bought 27 October 1997 | $9,391bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 June 1997 | $13,444 | $12,646bought 15 August 1997 | $12,975bought 27 October 1997 | $9,223bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 July 1997 | $11,541 | $11,484bought 15 August 1997 | $11,783bought 27 October 1997 | $8,375bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 August 1997 | $9,937 | $10,508bought 15 August 1997 | $10,781bought 27 October 1997 | $7,663bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 September 1997 | $10,452 | $10,696bought 11 September 1997 | $11,145bought 27 October 1997 | $7,922bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 October 1997 | $9,534 | $10,456bought 27 October 1997 | $10,456bought 27 October 1997 | $7,432bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 November 1997 | $10,213 | $10,330bought 7 November 1997 | $8,956bought 14 August 1998 | $7,827bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 December 1997 | $10,189 | $10,658bought 24 December 1997 | $9,324bought 14 August 1998 | $8,149bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 January 1998 | $9,937 | $10,502bought 9 January 1998 | $9,080bought 14 August 1998 | $7,935bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 February 1998 | $9,167 | $8,092bought 29 July 1998 | $8,580bought 14 August 1998 | $7,499bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 March 1998 | $8,615 | $7,983bought 29 July 1998 | $8,465bought 14 August 1998 | $7,397bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 April 1998 | $8,274 | $8,123bought 29 July 1998 | $8,613bought 14 August 1998 | $7,527bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 May 1998 | $8,699 | $8,676bought 29 July 1998 | $9,200bought 14 August 1998 | $8,040bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 June 1998 | $9,433 | $9,153bought 29 July 1998 | $9,705bought 14 August 1998 | $8,481bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 July 1998 | $9,165 | $9,335bought 29 July 1998 | $9,899bought 14 August 1998 | $8,651bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 August 1998 | $9,436 | $9,436same day | $9,897bought 14 August 1998 | $8,649bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 September 1998 | $10,809 | $10,809same day | $10,809same day | $8,906bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 October 1998 | $11,018 | $11,018same day | $11,018same day | $8,997bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 November 1998 | $10,038 | $10,038same day | $8,754bought 29 September 1999 | $9,281bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 December 1998 | $9,756 | $9,436bought 14 January 1999 | $8,945bought 29 September 1999 | $9,483bought 12 March 2001 |
| 4 January 1999 | $9,656 | $9,800bought 14 January 1999 | $9,291bought 29 September 1999 | $9,850bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 February 1999 | $9,550 | $9,372bought 25 May 1999 | $9,479bought 29 September 1999 | $10,049bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 March 1999 | $10,012 | $9,594bought 25 May 1999 | $9,703bought 29 September 1999 | $10,286bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 April 1999 | $9,405 | $9,430bought 25 May 1999 | $9,537bought 29 September 1999 | $10,111bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 May 1999 | $8,837 | $9,295bought 25 May 1999 | $9,400bought 29 September 1999 | $9,966bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 June 1999 | $9,288 | $9,288same day | $9,447bought 29 September 1999 | $10,016bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 July 1999 | $8,754 | $8,990bought 29 July 1999 | $9,501bought 29 September 1999 | $10,073bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 August 1999 | $8,930 | $8,930same day | $9,344bought 29 September 1999 | $9,906bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 September 1999 | $8,908 | $8,908same day | $9,365bought 29 September 1999 | $9,928bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 October 1999 | $9,477 | $9,477same day | $9,750bought 15 October 1999 | $10,178bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 November 1999 | $8,970 | $8,806bought 6 January 2000 | $8,760bought 10 May 2000 | $10,166bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 December 1999 | $9,124 | $9,277bought 6 January 2000 | $9,229bought 10 May 2000 | $10,710bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 January 2000 | $8,908 | $9,405bought 6 January 2000 | $9,355bought 10 May 2000 | $10,857bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 February 2000 | $9,086 | $9,233bought 11 February 2000 | $9,247bought 10 May 2000 | $10,731bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 March 2000 | $9,430 | $9,430same day | $9,428bought 10 May 2000 | $10,941bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 April 2000 | $8,372 | $8,688bought 4 April 2000 | $9,168bought 10 May 2000 | $10,639bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 May 2000 | $8,488 | $8,661bought 2 May 2000 | $9,037bought 10 May 2000 | $10,487bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 June 2000 | $8,942 | $8,942same day | $9,471bought 11 October 2000 | $10,918bought 12 March 2001 |
| 3 July 2000 | $8,766 | $8,927bought 5 July 2000 | $9,433bought 11 October 2000 | $10,873bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 August 2000 | $9,283 | $9,283same day | $9,758bought 11 October 2000 | $11,248bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 September 2000 | $8,683 | $9,123bought 18 September 2000 | $9,666bought 11 October 2000 | $11,143bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 October 2000 | $9,255 | $9,255same day | $9,751bought 11 October 2000 | $11,240bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 November 2000 | $9,151 | $9,151same day | $9,542bought 10 November 2000 | $11,007bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 December 2000 | $10,368 | $10,368same day | $10,368same day | $11,574bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 January 2001 | $10,482 | $10,482same day | $10,482same day | $11,435bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 February 2001 | $10,094 | $10,094same day | $10,329bought 2 February 2001 | $11,791bought 12 March 2001 |
| 1 March 2001 | $11,259 | $11,259same day | $11,259same day | $11,881bought 12 March 2001 |
| 2 April 2001 | $12,344 | $12,344same day | $12,344same day | $12,344same day |
| 1 May 2001 | $11,145 | $11,145same day | $11,145same day | $11,860bought 6 July 2001 |
| 1 June 2001 | $11,030 | $11,030same day | $11,030same day | $11,708bought 6 July 2001 |
| 2 July 2001 | $11,147 | $11,147same day | $11,147same day | $11,623bought 6 July 2001 |
| 1 August 2001 | $11,330 | $11,330same day | $11,330same day | $11,501bought 6 August 2001 |
| 4 September 2001 | $12,601 | $12,601same day | $12,601same day | $12,601same day |
| 1 October 2001 | $13,941 | $13,941same day | $13,941same day | $13,941same day |
| 1 November 2001 | $13,726 | $13,726same day | $13,726same day | $13,726same day |
| 3 December 2001 | $13,460 | $13,460same day | $13,460same day | $13,460same day |
| 2 January 2002 | $13,368 | $13,368same day | $13,368same day | $13,368same day |
| 1 February 2002 | $13,999 | $13,999same day | $13,999same day | $13,999same day |
| 1 March 2002 | $13,472 | $13,472same day | $13,472same day | $13,472same day |
| 1 April 2002 | $13,531 | $13,531same day | $13,531same day | $13,531same day |
| 1 May 2002 | $14,866 | $14,866same day | $14,866same day | $14,866same day |
| 3 June 2002 | $16,117 | $16,117same day | $16,117same day | $16,117same day |
| 1 July 2002 | $16,939 | $16,939same day | $16,939same day | $16,939same day |
| 1 August 2002 | $18,021 | $18,021same day | $18,021same day | $18,021same day |
| 3 September 2002 | $18,267 | $18,267same day | $18,267same day | $18,267same day |
| 1 October 2002 | $19,673 | $19,673same day | $19,673same day | $19,673same day |
| 1 November 2002 | $18,285 | $18,285same day | $18,285same day | $18,285same day |
| 2 December 2002 | $17,260 | $17,260same day | $17,260same day | $17,260same day |
| 2 January 2003 | $17,399 | $17,399same day | $17,399same day | $17,399same day |
| 3 February 2003 | $17,698 | $17,698same day | $17,698same day | $17,698same day |
| 3 March 2003 | $17,358 | $17,358same day | $17,358same day | $17,358same day |
| 1 April 2003 | $17,375 | $17,375same day | $17,375same day | $17,375same day |
| 1 May 2003 | $16,804 | $16,804same day | $16,804same day | $16,804same day |
| 2 June 2003 | $15,614 | $15,614same day | $15,614same day | $15,614same day |
| 1 July 2003 | $14,278 | $14,278same day | $14,278same day | $14,278same day |
| 1 August 2003 | $14,034 | $14,034same day | $14,034same day | $14,034same day |
| 2 September 2003 | $13,644 | $13,644same day | $13,644same day | $13,644same day |
| 1 October 2003 | $12,483 | $12,483same day | $12,483same day | $12,483same day |
| 3 November 2003 | $10,060 | $10,060same day | $10,060same day | $10,060same day |
| 1 December 2003 | $8,379 | $8,379same day | $8,379same day | $8,379same day |
| 2 January 2004 | $9,207 | $9,207same day | $9,207same day | $9,207same day |
| 2 February 2004 | $7,983 | $7,983same day | $7,983same day | $7,983same day |
| 1 March 2004 | $7,012 | $7,012same day | $7,012same day | $7,012same day |
| 1 April 2004 | $7,877 | $7,877same day | $7,877same day | $7,877same day |
| 3 May 2004 | $8,665 | $8,665same day | $8,665same day | $8,665same day |
| 1 June 2004 | $9,297 | $9,297same day | $9,297same day | $9,297same day |
| 1 July 2004 | $9,057 | $9,057same day | $9,057same day | $9,057same day |
| 2 August 2004 | $9,856 | $9,856same day | $9,856same day | $9,856same day |
| 1 September 2004 | $9,972 | $9,972same day | $9,972same day | $9,972same day |
| 1 October 2004 | $10,047 | $10,047same day | $10,047same day | $10,047same day |
| 1 November 2004 | $10,114 | $10,114same day | $10,114same day | $10,114same day |
| 1 December 2004 | $10,318 | $10,318same day | $10,318same day | $10,717bought 20 April 2005 |
| 3 January 2005 | $10,246 | $10,246same day | $10,246same day | $10,789bought 20 April 2005 |
| 1 February 2005 | $10,144 | $10,144same day | $10,144same day | $10,558bought 20 April 2005 |
| 1 March 2005 | $10,208 | $10,208same day | $10,208same day | $10,832bought 20 April 2005 |
| 1 April 2005 | $11,097 | $11,097same day | $11,097same day | $11,451bought 20 April 2005 |
| 2 May 2005 | $11,292 | $11,292same day | $11,292same day | $10,085bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 June 2005 | $9,872 | $9,872same day | $9,872same day | $9,128bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 July 2005 | $9,517 | $9,517same day | $9,517same day | $8,764bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 August 2005 | $9,873 | $9,873same day | $9,873same day | $9,405bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 September 2005 | $9,802 | $9,802same day | $9,802same day | $9,251bought 14 July 2008 |
| 3 October 2005 | $10,360 | $10,360same day | $10,360same day | $9,827bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 November 2005 | $10,902 | $10,902same day | $10,902same day | $10,164bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 December 2005 | $10,586 | $10,586same day | $10,586same day | $10,376bought 14 July 2008 |
| 3 January 2006 | $11,113 | $11,113same day | $11,177bought 20 January 2006 | $10,951bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 February 2006 | $11,285 | $11,285same day | $11,474bought 3 February 2006 | $11,269bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 March 2006 | $11,216 | $11,216same day | $11,546bought 23 May 2006 | $11,286bought 14 July 2008 |
| 3 April 2006 | $11,378 | $11,378same day | $11,793bought 23 May 2006 | $11,527bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 May 2006 | $11,599 | $11,599same day | $12,083bought 23 May 2006 | $11,811bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 June 2006 | $11,357 | $11,357same day | $11,616bought 7 June 2006 | $11,416bought 14 July 2008 |
| 3 July 2006 | $11,623 | $11,623same day | $11,979bought 13 July 2006 | $11,651bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 August 2006 | $11,228 | $11,228same day | $9,997bought 8 January 2008 | $11,204bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 September 2006 | $10,208 | $10,208same day | $9,388bought 8 January 2008 | $10,522bought 14 July 2008 |
| 2 October 2006 | $9,438 | $9,008bought 2 March 2007 | $8,829bought 8 January 2008 | $9,895bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 November 2006 | $9,895 | $9,712bought 2 March 2007 | $9,520bought 8 January 2008 | $10,669bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 December 2006 | $9,893 | $9,948bought 2 March 2007 | $9,751bought 8 January 2008 | $10,929bought 14 July 2008 |
| 3 January 2007 | $10,019 | $10,214bought 2 March 2007 | $10,011bought 8 January 2008 | $11,220bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 February 2007 | $10,177 | $10,612bought 2 March 2007 | $10,402bought 8 January 2008 | $11,658bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 March 2007 | $10,889 | $11,034bought 2 March 2007 | $10,815bought 8 January 2008 | $12,121bought 14 July 2008 |
| 2 April 2007 | $11,089 | $10,817bought 27 July 2007 | $11,187bought 8 January 2008 | $12,537bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 May 2007 | $10,521 | $10,733bought 27 July 2007 | $11,100bought 8 January 2008 | $12,440bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 June 2007 | $9,244 | $9,773bought 27 July 2007 | $10,108bought 8 January 2008 | $11,328bought 14 July 2008 |
| 2 July 2007 | $10,004 | $10,464bought 27 July 2007 | $10,822bought 8 January 2008 | $12,129bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 August 2007 | $10,452 | $10,452same day | $10,908bought 8 January 2008 | $12,225bought 14 July 2008 |
| 4 September 2007 | $10,523 | $10,740bought 7 September 2007 | $11,180bought 8 January 2008 | $12,530bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 October 2007 | $10,412 | $10,862bought 7 November 2007 | $11,504bought 8 January 2008 | $12,893bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 November 2007 | $10,526 | $10,748bought 7 November 2007 | $11,384bought 8 January 2008 | $12,758bought 14 July 2008 |
| 3 December 2007 | $10,660 | $10,660same day | $11,274bought 8 January 2008 | $12,635bought 14 July 2008 |
| 2 January 2008 | $11,237 | $11,237same day | $11,724bought 8 January 2008 | $13,139bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 February 2008 | $12,081 | $12,081same day | $12,081same day | $13,605bought 14 July 2008 |
| 3 March 2008 | $12,704 | $12,704same day | $12,704same day | $13,683bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 April 2008 | $12,730 | $12,730same day | $12,730same day | $14,100bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 May 2008 | $12,499 | $12,499same day | $12,675bought 8 May 2008 | $14,302bought 14 July 2008 |
| 2 June 2008 | $13,113 | $13,113same day | $13,113same day | $14,768bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 July 2008 | $14,011 | $14,011same day | $14,011same day | $14,657bought 14 July 2008 |
| 1 August 2008 | $15,079 | $15,079same day | $15,079same day | $15,439bought 9 September 2008 |
| 2 September 2008 | $14,253 | $14,253same day | $14,253same day | $14,805bought 9 September 2008 |
| 1 October 2008 | $16,250 | $16,250same day | $16,250same day | $16,250same day |
| 3 November 2008 | $20,209 | $20,209same day | $20,209same day | $20,209same day |
| 1 December 2008 | $24,550 | $24,550same day | $24,550same day | $24,550same day |
| 2 January 2009 | $21,857 | $21,857same day | $21,857same day | $21,857same day |
| 2 February 2009 | $23,966 | $23,966same day | $23,966same day | $23,966same day |
| 2 March 2009 | $29,309 | $29,309same day | $29,309same day | $29,309same day |
| 1 April 2009 | $25,725 | $25,725same day | $25,725same day | $25,725same day |
| 1 May 2009 | $23,735 | $23,735same day | $23,735same day | $23,735same day |
| 1 June 2009 | $22,521 | $22,521same day | $22,521same day | $22,521same day |
| 1 July 2009 | $23,618 | $23,618same day | $23,618same day | $23,618same day |
| 3 August 2009 | $21,212 | $21,212same day | $21,212same day | $21,212same day |
| 1 September 2009 | $22,170 | $22,170same day | $22,170same day | $22,170same day |
| 1 October 2009 | $20,882 | $20,882same day | $20,882same day | $20,882same day |
| 2 November 2009 | $21,393 | $21,393same day | $21,393same day | $21,393same day |
| 1 December 2009 | $20,459 | $20,459same day | $20,459same day | $20,459same day |
| 4 January 2010 | $20,063 | $20,063same day | $20,063same day | $20,063same day |
| 1 February 2010 | $20,241 | $20,241same day | $20,241same day | $20,241same day |
| 1 March 2010 | $20,838 | $20,838same day | $20,838same day | $20,838same day |
| 1 April 2010 | $19,334 | $19,334same day | $19,334same day | $19,334same day |
| 3 May 2010 | $19,386 | $19,386same day | $19,386same day | $19,853bought 4 May 2010 |
| 1 June 2010 | $21,784 | $21,784same day | $21,784same day | $21,784same day |
| 1 July 2010 | $22,359 | $22,359same day | $22,359same day | $22,359same day |
| 2 August 2010 | $20,671 | $20,671same day | $20,671same day | $20,671same day |
| 1 September 2010 | $19,578 | $19,578same day | $19,578same day | $19,578same day |
| 1 October 2010 | $18,560 | $18,560same day | $18,560same day | $18,560same day |
| 1 November 2010 | $19,422 | $19,422same day | $19,422same day | $20,211bought 8 August 2011 |
| 1 December 2010 | $19,275 | $19,275same day | $19,275same day | $20,478bought 8 August 2011 |
| 3 January 2011 | $17,778 | $17,778same day | $17,778same day | $19,934bought 8 August 2011 |
| 1 February 2011 | $16,410 | $16,410same day | $16,410same day | $18,935bought 8 August 2011 |
| 1 March 2011 | $16,764 | $16,764same day | $16,764same day | $19,371bought 8 August 2011 |
| 1 April 2011 | $17,231 | $17,231same day | $17,592bought 3 June 2011 | $20,337bought 8 August 2011 |
| 2 May 2011 | $16,928 | $16,928same day | $17,681bought 3 June 2011 | $20,440bought 8 August 2011 |
| 1 June 2011 | $17,680 | $17,680same day | $17,876bought 3 June 2011 | $20,666bought 8 August 2011 |
| 1 July 2011 | $17,385 | $17,385same day | $18,002bought 29 July 2011 | $20,739bought 8 August 2011 |
| 1 August 2011 | $18,683 | $18,683same day | $18,683same day | $21,432bought 8 August 2011 |
| 1 September 2011 | $19,935 | $19,935same day | $19,935same day | $21,253bought 22 September 2011 |
| 3 October 2011 | $21,767 | $21,767same day | $21,767same day | $21,767same day |
| 1 November 2011 | $19,180 | $19,180same day | $19,180same day | $10,000never |
| 1 December 2011 | $19,484 | $19,484same day | $19,484same day | $10,000never |
| 3 January 2012 | $19,582 | $19,582same day | $19,582same day | $10,000never |
| 1 February 2012 | $19,046 | $19,046same day | $12,403bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 March 2012 | $19,297 | $19,724bought 6 March 2012 | $13,066bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 April 2012 | $18,422 | $19,484bought 14 May 2012 | $12,902bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 May 2012 | $18,797 | $19,727bought 14 May 2012 | $13,063bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 June 2012 | $21,047 | $21,047same day | $13,319bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 July 2012 | $19,627 | $19,974bought 10 July 2012 | $13,298bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 August 2012 | $19,918 | $19,747bought 8 November 2012 | $13,602bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 4 September 2012 | $19,473 | $19,789bought 8 November 2012 | $13,630bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 October 2012 | $19,278 | $20,159bought 8 November 2012 | $13,885bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 November 2012 | $19,968 | $20,661bought 8 November 2012 | $14,231bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 3 December 2012 | $20,709 | $18,340bought 24 June 2013 | $14,616bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 January 2013 | $20,342 | $18,734bought 24 June 2013 | $14,931bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 February 2013 | $20,582 | $19,627bought 24 June 2013 | $15,642bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 March 2013 | $19,455 | $18,660bought 24 June 2013 | $14,871bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 April 2013 | $18,634 | $18,416bought 24 June 2013 | $14,677bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 May 2013 | $18,499 | $18,544bought 24 June 2013 | $14,779bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 3 June 2013 | $18,395 | $19,148bought 24 June 2013 | $15,260bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 July 2013 | $18,562 | $17,021bought 3 February 2014 | $15,198bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 August 2013 | $18,170 | $17,622bought 3 February 2014 | $15,735bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 3 September 2013 | $19,498 | $18,215bought 3 February 2014 | $16,264bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 October 2013 | $19,014 | $18,387bought 3 February 2014 | $16,418bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 November 2013 | $17,132 | $17,239bought 3 February 2014 | $15,393bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 December 2013 | $16,853 | $17,374bought 3 February 2014 | $15,513bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 January 2014 | $15,102 | $15,860bought 3 February 2014 | $14,162bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 3 February 2014 | $17,121 | $17,121same day | $15,287bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 3 March 2014 | $16,739 | $16,027bought 10 October 2014 | $15,874bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 April 2014 | $16,765 | $16,408bought 10 October 2014 | $16,251bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 May 2014 | $17,109 | $16,751bought 10 October 2014 | $16,591bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 June 2014 | $15,757 | $15,802bought 10 October 2014 | $15,651bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 July 2014 | $16,570 | $17,055bought 10 October 2014 | $16,892bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 August 2014 | $16,913 | $17,007bought 10 October 2014 | $16,845bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 September 2014 | $16,098 | $16,870bought 10 October 2014 | $16,708bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 October 2014 | $16,660 | $16,993bought 10 October 2014 | $16,831bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 3 November 2014 | $16,753 | $16,853bought 21 August 2015 | $17,571bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 December 2014 | $16,867 | $17,303bought 21 August 2015 | $18,040bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 January 2015 | $17,451 | $17,972bought 21 August 2015 | $18,738bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 February 2015 | $17,583 | $17,798bought 21 August 2015 | $18,557bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 2 March 2015 | $16,090 | $17,099bought 21 August 2015 | $17,828bought 24 August 2015 | $10,000never |
| 1 April 2015 | $13,224 | $13,697bought 21 August 2015 | $14,281bought 24 August 2015 | $9,979bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 May 2015 | $14,830 | $15,736bought 21 August 2015 | $16,407bought 24 August 2015 | $11,465bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 June 2015 | $15,959 | $17,002bought 21 August 2015 | $17,727bought 24 August 2015 | $12,388bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 July 2015 | $16,530 | $17,355bought 21 August 2015 | $18,095bought 24 August 2015 | $12,644bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 August 2015 | $17,311 | $18,376bought 21 August 2015 | $19,159bought 24 August 2015 | $13,388bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 September 2015 | $20,309 | $20,309same day | $20,608bought 28 September 2015 | $14,358bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 October 2015 | $19,353 | $19,353same day | $19,575bought 13 January 2016 | $13,779bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 November 2015 | $17,315 | $18,214bought 6 January 2016 | $19,178bought 13 January 2016 | $13,500bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 December 2015 | $19,167 | $20,190bought 6 January 2016 | $21,258bought 13 January 2016 | $14,964bought 12 March 2020 |
| 4 January 2016 | $20,206 | $20,430bought 6 January 2016 | $21,510bought 13 January 2016 | $15,142bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 February 2016 | $21,398 | $21,398same day | $22,047bought 5 February 2016 | $15,447bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 March 2016 | $21,659 | $21,659same day | $15,994bought 8 February 2018 | $15,995bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 April 2016 | $21,284 | $21,950bought 27 June 2016 | $16,501bought 8 February 2018 | $16,502bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 May 2016 | $22,059 | $22,865bought 27 June 2016 | $17,188bought 8 February 2018 | $17,189bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 June 2016 | $21,941 | $22,994bought 27 June 2016 | $17,286bought 8 February 2018 | $17,287bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 July 2016 | $22,498 | $17,362bought 5 February 2018 | $17,787bought 8 February 2018 | $17,788bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 August 2016 | $22,179 | $17,688bought 5 February 2018 | $18,121bought 8 February 2018 | $18,122bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 September 2016 | $22,803 | $18,224bought 5 February 2018 | $18,670bought 8 February 2018 | $18,671bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 October 2016 | $22,040 | $17,572bought 5 February 2018 | $18,002bought 8 February 2018 | $18,003bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 November 2016 | $23,877 | $18,616bought 5 February 2018 | $19,071bought 8 February 2018 | $19,073bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 December 2016 | $22,471 | $18,230bought 5 February 2018 | $18,676bought 8 February 2018 | $18,677bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 January 2017 | $23,173 | $19,399bought 5 February 2018 | $19,873bought 8 February 2018 | $19,875bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 February 2017 | $21,742 | $18,394bought 5 February 2018 | $18,843bought 8 February 2018 | $18,845bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 March 2017 | $19,593 | $17,461bought 5 February 2018 | $17,888bought 8 February 2018 | $17,889bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 April 2017 | $21,003 | $18,450bought 5 February 2018 | $18,901bought 8 February 2018 | $18,902bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 May 2017 | $18,837 | $16,783bought 5 February 2018 | $17,193bought 8 February 2018 | $17,194bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 June 2017 | $18,367 | $16,685bought 5 February 2018 | $17,093bought 8 February 2018 | $17,094bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 July 2017 | $17,167 | $15,597bought 5 February 2018 | $15,978bought 8 February 2018 | $15,979bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 August 2017 | $18,115 | $16,805bought 5 February 2018 | $17,216bought 8 February 2018 | $17,217bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 September 2017 | $17,445 | $16,218bought 5 February 2018 | $16,614bought 8 February 2018 | $16,616bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 October 2017 | $15,426 | $14,673bought 5 February 2018 | $15,031bought 8 February 2018 | $15,033bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 November 2017 | $16,273 | $15,796bought 5 February 2018 | $16,182bought 8 February 2018 | $16,183bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 December 2017 | $16,787 | $16,735bought 5 February 2018 | $17,144bought 8 February 2018 | $17,145bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 January 2018 | $15,498 | $15,782bought 5 February 2018 | $16,168bought 8 February 2018 | $16,169bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 February 2018 | $15,890 | $16,953bought 5 February 2018 | $17,367bought 8 February 2018 | $17,369bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 March 2018 | $16,060 | $16,060same day | $16,293bought 14 December 2018 | $16,690bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 April 2018 | $17,315 | $17,315same day | $16,962bought 14 December 2018 | $17,375bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 May 2018 | $17,076 | $17,076same day | $17,216bought 14 December 2018 | $17,635bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 June 2018 | $16,789 | $16,978bought 27 June 2018 | $17,477bought 14 December 2018 | $17,903bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 July 2018 | $17,742 | $17,642bought 11 October 2018 | $18,435bought 14 December 2018 | $18,883bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 August 2018 | $17,685 | $18,168bought 11 October 2018 | $18,984bought 14 December 2018 | $19,446bought 12 March 2020 |
| 4 September 2018 | $16,941 | $17,957bought 11 October 2018 | $18,764bought 14 December 2018 | $19,220bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 October 2018 | $15,929 | $17,074bought 11 October 2018 | $17,840bought 14 December 2018 | $18,274bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 November 2018 | $16,798 | $16,798same day | $17,639bought 14 December 2018 | $18,068bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 December 2018 | $17,868 | $18,467bought 4 December 2018 | $19,160bought 14 December 2018 | $19,626bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 January 2019 | $20,500 | $20,500same day | $20,500same day | $20,287bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 February 2019 | $19,656 | $19,656same day | $17,511bought 27 February 2020 | $20,998bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 March 2019 | $19,845 | $20,236bought 7 March 2019 | $18,358bought 27 February 2020 | $22,013bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 April 2019 | $19,798 | $20,335bought 29 May 2019 | $18,749bought 27 February 2020 | $22,482bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 May 2019 | $18,582 | $19,486bought 29 May 2019 | $17,966bought 27 February 2020 | $21,543bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 June 2019 | $20,832 | $20,832same day | $18,952bought 27 February 2020 | $22,725bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 July 2019 | $19,956 | $20,789bought 5 August 2019 | $19,645bought 27 February 2020 | $23,556bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 August 2019 | $19,926 | $20,700bought 5 August 2019 | $19,561bought 27 February 2020 | $23,455bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 September 2019 | $20,545 | $18,924bought 25 February 2020 | $19,887bought 27 February 2020 | $23,847bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 October 2019 | $20,948 | $19,551bought 25 February 2020 | $20,546bought 27 February 2020 | $24,637bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 November 2019 | $20,150 | $19,634bought 25 February 2020 | $20,633bought 27 February 2020 | $24,742bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 December 2019 | $20,924 | $20,755bought 25 February 2020 | $21,811bought 27 February 2020 | $26,154bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 January 2020 | $19,411 | $20,170bought 25 February 2020 | $21,196bought 27 February 2020 | $25,416bought 12 March 2020 |
| 3 February 2020 | $19,893 | $20,622bought 25 February 2020 | $21,672bought 27 February 2020 | $25,987bought 12 March 2020 |
| 2 March 2020 | $20,735 | $20,735same day | $21,346bought 3 March 2020 | $25,831bought 12 March 2020 |
| 1 April 2020 | $24,511 | $24,511same day | $24,511same day | $24,511same day |
| 1 May 2020 | $21,240 | $21,240same day | $21,240same day | $15,560bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 June 2020 | $20,746 | $20,746same day | $21,087bought 11 June 2020 | $16,421bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 July 2020 | $21,362 | $21,362same day | $15,114bought 22 February 2022 | $17,259bought 13 June 2022 |
| 3 August 2020 | $20,308 | $20,039bought 8 September 2020 | $15,213bought 22 February 2022 | $17,373bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 September 2020 | $19,648 | $20,791bought 8 September 2020 | $15,784bought 22 February 2022 | $18,025bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 October 2020 | $21,274 | $21,274same day | $16,402bought 22 February 2022 | $18,731bought 13 June 2022 |
| 2 November 2020 | $22,157 | $22,157same day | $16,736bought 22 February 2022 | $19,112bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 December 2020 | $19,936 | $16,768bought 30 September 2021 | $16,692bought 22 February 2022 | $19,062bought 13 June 2022 |
| 4 January 2021 | $19,845 | $16,889bought 30 September 2021 | $16,813bought 22 February 2022 | $19,200bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 February 2021 | $19,703 | $17,107bought 30 September 2021 | $17,029bought 22 February 2022 | $19,447bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 March 2021 | $18,863 | $16,959bought 30 September 2021 | $16,882bought 22 February 2022 | $19,279bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 April 2021 | $17,512 | $16,243bought 30 September 2021 | $16,170bought 22 February 2022 | $18,465bought 13 June 2022 |
| 3 May 2021 | $18,450 | $17,864bought 30 September 2021 | $17,784bought 22 February 2022 | $20,308bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 June 2021 | $19,352 | $18,803bought 30 September 2021 | $18,719bought 22 February 2022 | $21,376bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 July 2021 | $18,538 | $18,534bought 30 September 2021 | $18,451bought 22 February 2022 | $21,070bought 13 June 2022 |
| 2 August 2021 | $18,266 | $18,566bought 30 September 2021 | $18,482bought 22 February 2022 | $21,106bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 September 2021 | $18,040 | $18,932bought 30 September 2021 | $18,847bought 22 February 2022 | $21,523bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 October 2021 | $18,811 | $19,057bought 4 October 2021 | $18,949bought 22 February 2022 | $21,639bought 13 June 2022 |
| 1 November 2021 | $17,564 | $17,823bought 19 January 2022 | $18,744bought 22 February 2022 | $21,405bought 13 June 2022 |
Every start month, $10,000 each, values after 5 years.
Wait for a dip vs invest now: Indices Lab study on SPY, dividends reinvested, 29 January 1993 to 20 November 2026. Data: EODHD. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
| Wait for a drop of | Waiting won | Same day (already in a dip) | Investing now won | Dip never came within 5 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Five percent | 28.9% | 46.2% | 24.9% | 0.0% |
| Ten percent | 28.0% | 31.2% | 40.8% | 0.0% |
| Twenty percent | 32.9% | 19.1% | 48.0% | 22.8% |
In money, $10,000 invested at once was worth $17,068 after five years on average. Waiting for a five percent dip averaged $16,763, a ten percent dip $15,393, and a twenty percent dip $13,799. The deeper the dip you hold out for, the longer you wait: the typical wait for twenty percent was 378 days, and in 22.8% of start months it never came within five years. Start in January 2013 and wait for twenty percent, and five years later you still held the $10,000 in cash, while the money invested at once had roughly doubled.
The ten-year check tells the same story: waiting won in 26.2% of start months for a ten percent dip and 27.3% for a twenty percent dip.
Where the myth has a point
It does pay sometimes, and when it does, it can pay well. Start in October 2007, just before the financial crisis, wait for a twenty percent drop, and five years later you were well ahead of someone who invested at once. Small dips are close to a wash: in the months when the two investors bought on different days, waiting for a five percent dip came out ahead in 53.8% of them. That, and the many months when both bought the same day, is why the verdict is It depends, not Busted. What the data doesn't support is "always": the big wins come from starting just before a crash, which nobody can tell at the time, and the losses come from everything else.
What it means for your portfolio
If you have cash to invest, the record says waiting for a dip is more likely to cost you than pay you, and holding out for a big one cost the most. Two things help more than timing: a portfolio whose falls you can sit through, so a dip is something you hold through rather than wait for, and a fixed plan for new money, all at once or in set monthly amounts, that doesn't depend on guessing the next drop. You can test the first in a backtest: see what your mix did through 2008, 2020 and 2022 before you own it. For other sayings we've tested, see does gold beat the S&P 500? and are dividend stocks safer in a crash?.
Questions
Is buying the dip a good strategy?
As a way to invest new cash, waiting for a dip beat investing straight away in under a third of start months since 1993 on SPY. It works when you happen to start near a peak; most of the time the market rises before the dip comes.
How big a dip should I wait for?
In this test, the bigger the dip, the bigger the average cost, because you wait longer and the dip often starts from a higher price. A twenty percent dip didn't come within five years in nearly a quarter of start months.
Is it better to invest a lump sum or wait?
On this test, investing at once ended ahead on average for every dip size, and for ten percent and twenty percent dips it also won more often than waiting did. Spreading the money over a few months is a middle path; that's a different test.
What about buying more when the market falls, with money I already planned to invest?
That's rebalancing or regular investing, which this test doesn't cover: it only looks at holding cash back to wait for a dip.
About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.