Guide
Stocks vs bonds: what each did in every crash, tested
Over the long run stocks grew far faster than bonds, but bonds did not cushion every crash: from 10 April 2007 to 20 November 2026, the stock fund SPY grew 10.3% a year against 2.9% for the bond fund BND. BND returned +6.9% in 2008, when SPY returned −36.8%, but −13.1% in 2022, when stocks and bonds fell together.
What stocks and bonds are
A stock is a small share of a company. Its value rises and falls with the company's profits and with what other investors will pay for them, so it can grow a lot or fall a long way. A bond is a loan: you lend money to a government or a company, and it pays you interest and returns the loan on a set date. Bonds usually swing less, because the payments are fixed in advance.
Most people own both through funds that hold hundreds or thousands of them. The trap is that "bonds" is not one thing. A bond fund's price moves opposite to interest rates: when rates rise, older bonds paying less interest are worth less. The longer a fund's bonds have until they are repaid, the bigger that effect. This sensitivity to rates is called duration, and it is why two bond funds can behave very differently in the same year.
Stocks and bonds side by side
Stocks
- A share of a company
- Paid from profits, nothing fixed
- Can grow a lot
- Can fall a long way
Bonds
- A loan to a government or company
- Fixed interest and repayment
- Price moves opposite to rates
- Longer bonds move more
The follow-along example
We test three funds on their own and one mix, each starting with $10,000, dividends and interest reinvested, from 10 April 2007 (the first day all three funds have prices) to 20 November 2026.
Follow along: the four portfolios
Portfolio What it holds Rule SPY US large-company stocks (the S&P 500 fund) Held; our benchmark BND The whole US investment-grade bond market, medium duration Held TLT US government bonds repaid in 20 years or more, long duration Held SPY 60 / BND 40 60% stocks, 40% bonds Reset to 60/40 once a year 60/40 means six-tenths of the money in stocks and four-tenths in bonds. Rebalancing means selling some of whatever has grown and buying what has lagged, to get back to those weights. The benchmark is the yardstick: everything is measured against SPY.
How we tested this
Step 1: Look at the worst fall first
Start with the number that decides whether you can stick with a portfolio: its max drawdown, the largest fall from a high to a later low (max drawdown explained). Long government bonds fell almost as far as stocks, and the total bond fund's worst fall came in the bond crash after 2020, not in 2008.
- SPY 60 / BND 40 worst fall 33.7% (9 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 3.1 years
- BND (bonds) worst fall 18.8% (6 August 2020 to 20 October 2022), longest time below a previous high 6.3 years
- TLT (long Treasuries) worst fall 48.4% (4 August 2020 to 19 October 2023), longest time below a previous high 6.3 years
- SPY (stocks) worst fall 55.2% (9 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 4.9 years
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 10 April 2007 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Follow along: the deepest fall and the longest wait
Portfolio Max drawdown Longest time below a previous high SPY 55.2% 4.9 years BND 18.8% 6.3 years TLT 48.4% 6.3 years SPY 60 / BND 40 33.7% 3.1 years The surprise is the right-hand column. SPY's worst fall was the deepest, but both bond funds spent longer below their old high than SPY ever did, because their long stretch began in 2020 and the interest they pay rebuilds value slowly. A smaller fall is not the same as a shorter wait.
Step 2: Check each crash year on its own
"Bonds go up when stocks go down" is the most repeated line about the two. Test it year by year, because it depends on why stocks are falling.
| 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPY 60 / BND 40 | −19.3% | +17.3% | +11.5% | +4.3% | +11.1% | +18.5% | +10.4% | +1.0% | +8.2% | +14.5% | −2.8% | +22.3% | +14.0% | +16.4% | −16.2% | +18.0% | +15.5% | +13.5% |
| BND (bonds) | +6.9% | +3.6% | +6.2% | +7.9% | +3.9% | −2.1% | +5.8% | +0.6% | +2.5% | +3.6% | −0.1% | +8.8% | +7.5% | −2.0% | −13.1% | +5.7% | +1.4% | +7.1% |
| TLT (long Treasuries) | +33.9% | −21.8% | +9.0% | +34.0% | +2.6% | −13.4% | +27.3% | −1.8% | +1.2% | +9.2% | −1.6% | +14.1% | +18.2% | −4.6% | −31.2% | +2.8% | −8.1% | +4.2% |
| SPY (stocks) | −36.8% | +26.4% | +15.1% | +1.9% | +16.0% | +32.3% | +13.5% | +1.2% | +12.0% | +21.7% | −4.6% | +31.2% | +18.3% | +28.7% | −18.2% | +26.2% | +24.9% | +17.7% |
Full calendar years only. Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 10 April 2007 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Follow along: the years stocks fell
Year SPY BND TLT SPY 60 / BND 40 2008 −36.8% +6.9% +33.9% −19.3% 2018 −4.6% −0.1% −1.6% −2.8% 2022 −18.2% −13.1% −31.2% −16.2% In 2008 the economy was in trouble, interest rates were cut, and bonds rose while stocks fell: TLT, the long fund, did best. In 2022 the problem was inflation, rates went up fast, and everything fell in the same year. TLT, the best cushion in 2008, lost the most of the three funds in 2022.
So the cushion works when stocks fall because growth is weak and rates come down, and fails when stocks fall because rates go up. Long-duration bonds amplify both cases.
Step 3: Compare growth over the whole period
Now the long run. Read growth as CAGR, the compound annual growth rate: the steady yearly rate that turns the start value into the end value (how CAGR works).
- SPY 60 / BND 40 $42,993
- BND (bonds) $17,601
- TLT (long Treasuries) $17,247
- SPY (stocks) $68,107
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 10 April 2007 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Follow along: the whole period
Portfolio CAGR Gap to SPY, per year End value SPY 10.3% $68,107 BND 2.9% −7.4 points $17,601 TLT 2.8% −7.5 points $17,247 SPY 60 / BND 40 7.7% −2.6 points $42,993 Stocks ended far ahead. TLT fell almost as far as stocks in Step 1, yet grew no faster than the much calmer BND: it took stock-sized risk for a bond-sized return.
Step 4: Check every start date
One start date can flatter or punish anything. A rolling window test takes every possible 5-year or 10-year stretch, one per month, and counts how often each portfolio finished ahead of SPY. The chart shows the 60/40 mix against SPY in every 10-year window.
SPY 60 / BND 40 finished ahead of SPY (stocks) in 0.0% of 116 rolling 10-year windows (window ends by month).
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 10 April 2007 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Follow along: how often bonds beat stocks
Portfolio Ahead of SPY in 5-year windows Ahead in 10-year windows Last 5-year window it won ended BND 7.4% of 176 0.0% of 116 May 2013 TLT 9.7% of 176 1.7% of 116 March 2020 SPY 60 / BND 40 8.5% of 176 0.0% of 116 June 2013 Almost every 5-year window that bonds won started between 2007 and mid-2008, near the old stock high, and ran through the 2008 crash. TLT also won two that ended in a stock sell-off, the last in the 2020 crash. In calendar years they did better than SPY more often: BND in 22.2% of full years.
Two traps here. The 10-year windows overlap heavily, so treat them as one long result, not a hundred tests. And stocks rose strongly for most of this history; a long stock slump such as 2000 to 2002 is not in the test.
Step 5: Split the history in two
Bonds' returns depend on where interest rates start and where they go. Split the test at its midpoint and the two halves tell opposite stories.
Follow along: growth per year in each half
Portfolio First half Second half SPY 7.0% 13.6% BND 4.2% 1.7% TLT 6.8% -1.0% SPY 60 / BND 40 6.5% 9.0% In the first half, with rates falling, long government bonds kept pace with stocks and finished slightly ahead. In the second half, with rates ending well above where they started, TLT lost money over almost ten years.
In the first half, TLT and SPY finished close together:
- SPY 60 / BND 40 $18,458
- BND (bonds) $14,926
- TLT (long Treasuries) $18,985
- SPY (stocks) $19,451
First half: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 10 April 2007 to 26 January 2017. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
The lesson: a bond fund's past return mostly tells you what rates did. When you judge bonds on a backtest, ask what rates were at the start and what they are now.
Step 6: Mix them and measure the ride
The case for holding both is not that bonds earn more. It is that the mix can give more return for each unit of swing. Volatility measures how much a portfolio swings up and down, as a yearly percentage. The Sharpe ratio divides return by volatility, so higher means more return per unit of swing (the risk ratios compared).
| Basket | Yearly return | Volatility | Sharpe | Worst drop | $10,000 became |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPY 60 / BND 40 | 7.7% | 11.5% | 0.71 | 33.7% | $42,993 |
| BND (bonds) | 2.9% | 5.2% | 0.58 | 18.8% | $17,601 |
| TLT (long Treasuries) | 2.8% | 15.1% | 0.26 | 48.4% | $17,247 |
| SPY (stocks) | 10.3% | 19.6% | 0.60 | 55.2% | $68,107 |
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, single funds held throughout, 10 April 2007 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns. Sharpe uses a 0% risk-free rate.
Follow along: return for the risk taken
Portfolio Volatility Sharpe Sortino SPY 19.6% 0.60 0.84 BND 5.2% 0.58 0.83 TLT 15.1% 0.26 0.37 SPY 60 / BND 40 11.5% 0.71 1.00 The 60/40 mix had a higher Sharpe ratio than SPY or BND on its own: holding both gave more return per unit of swing than either part. Its growth gap to SPY was −2.6 points a year: the price of a worst fall of 33.7% instead of 55.2%.
The Sortino ratio is the same idea counting only downward swings. For more mixes, including three-fund and All Weather portfolios, see lazy portfolios backtested.
What this example can't show
It starts in 2007, when BND began trading, so it misses the 2000 to 2002 bear market and the high-inflation 1970s. It covers mostly falling rates, then one sharp rise. It tests US funds only, and not cash or short-term bonds. And it uses no costs or taxes: bond interest is often taxed more heavily than stock gains.
Before you choose a stock and bond mix
- Look at the worst fall and the longest wait
- Check each crash year on its own
- Know your bond fund's duration
- Test every start date, not one
- Split the history in two
- Ask what rates were at the start
- Compare return per unit of swing
Test your own stock and bond mix over the same dates, then change the weights and the bond fund and see what moves.
Questions
Are bonds safer than stocks?
They swing less, but not always by as much as people expect. From 10 April 2007, the total bond fund BND had a worst fall of 18.8% against 55.2% for SPY, while the long government bond fund TLT fell 48.4%. How far a bond fund can fall depends mostly on its duration.
Do bonds go up when stocks go down?
Sometimes. In 2008, when rates were cut, BND returned +6.9% and TLT +33.9% while SPY returned −36.8%. In 2022, when rates rose to fight inflation, all three fell in the same year.
Why did bonds fall in 2022?
Interest rates rose quickly, and a bond fund's price moves opposite to rates: older bonds paying less interest became worth less. Funds holding long bonds fell most; TLT returned −31.2% that year.
Do stocks always beat bonds over 10 years?
In this test, BND finished ahead of SPY in 0.0% of 116 ten-year windows. The test starts in 2007, so it misses long stock slumps such as 2000 to 2002.
What is a 60/40 portfolio?
A mix with 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds, reset to those weights on a schedule. Here SPY 60 / BND 40, reset once a year, grew 7.7% a year with a worst fall of 33.7%.
About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.