Myth
Does Buffett's 90/10 beat Ray Dalio's All Weather portfolio?
Yes on return, at a price. From 3 February 2006 Buffett's 90/10 (SPY 90 / SHY 10) grew 9.8% a year against 6.4% for All Weather and led in 84.6% of 10-year windows, but its worst fall was 50.2% against 23.8%.
The myth, and why people believe it
Buffett's 90/10 comes from Warren Buffett's 2013 letter to shareholders, where he described what his own estate's trustee should do with the cash left to his wife: put nine-tenths in a low-cost S&P 500 index fund and one-tenth in short-term government bonds. That is all 90/10 means here.
The All Weather portfolio is the simplified version of Ray Dalio's approach that he shared for individual investors and that a 2014 book by Tony Robbins made famous: 30% in stocks, 40% in long-term US government bonds, 15% in intermediate ones, 7.5% in gold and 7.5% in commodities. The idea is to hold something that does well in each kind of economy (growth, recession, inflation, deflation), so the whole mix holds up whatever happens.
People expect Buffett to win because stocks have grown faster than bonds over long periods, and 90/10 is nine-tenths stocks. All Weather is less than a third stocks, so the common view is that it trades return for calm.
How we tested it
We built both from funds you can buy. Buffett's 90/10 is SPY 90 / SHY 10 (SHY holds US Treasuries maturing in one to three years). All Weather is VTI, TLT, IEF, GLD and DBC in the weights above. Both are rebalanced once a year, which means selling what grew and buying what shrank to get back to the starting weights. DBC, the youngest fund, sets the start, so the test runs from 3 February 2006 to 20 November 2026, with dividends reinvested. As a reference we added a plain 60/40, which means 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds (SPY 60 / IEF 40).
All Weather is the benchmark. "Beats" means grew faster, over the whole period and over every 10-year stretch, month by month. Before looking, we set the line: the myth is busted if 90/10 grew more slowly over the whole period or led in fewer than three in ten 10-year windows; proven if it grew at least one percentage point a year faster and led in at least seven in ten windows; otherwise it depends.
How we tested this
The result
Buffett's 90/10 ended with about twice as much money, and it led in most 10-year windows.
- SPY 90 / SHY 10 $69,945
- SPY 60 / IEF 40 $50,269
- All Weather $36,269
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, 3 February 2006 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Test Result $10,000 in Buffett's 90/10 became $69,945 $10,000 in All Weather became $36,269 Yearly growth, 90/10 9.8% Yearly growth, All Weather 6.4% Yearly growth, 60/40 8.1% 90/10 ahead over 10 years 84.6% of 130 windows 90/10 ahead over 5 years 83.7% of 190 windows 90/10 ahead in calendar years 73.7%
SPY 90 / SHY 10 finished ahead of All Weather in 84.6% of 130 rolling 10-year windows (window ends by month). The last window SPY 90 / SHY 10 won ended November 2026.
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, 3 February 2006 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Every 10-year window All Weather won started in 2006 or 2007, just before the 2008 crash. Split the history in half and the same thing shows: in the first half All Weather grew 7.7% a year against 6.6% for 90/10; in the second half 90/10 grew 13.2% against 5.0%.
90/10 grew more than one percentage point a year faster and led in more than seven in ten windows, so under the rule we set the myth is proven.
What the verdict leaves out
The return came with much deeper falls. 90/10's worst fall was 50.2%, against 23.8% for All Weather, and it swung about twice as much from day to day (volatility, the usual measure of how much a portfolio's value jumps around, was 17.0% against 8.1%).
- SPY 90 / SHY 10 worst fall 50.2% (9 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 4.4 years
- SPY 60 / IEF 40 worst fall 29.8% (9 October 2007 to 9 March 2009), longest time below a previous high 2.5 years
- All Weather worst fall 23.8% (9 November 2021 to 20 October 2022), longest time below a previous high 3.8 years
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, mixes rebalanced yearly, 3 February 2006 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
Per unit of that swing, All Weather did better: its Sharpe ratio, return divided by volatility, was 0.81 against 0.64. In 2008 the difference was stark.
Year Buffett's 90/10 All Weather 60/40 2008 −32.5% +3.2% −14.9% 2013 +29.1% +1.1% +16.9% 2022 −16.7% −19.2% −17.0%
But All Weather's calm depends on long-term bonds, and they failed it once. In 2022, when both stocks and bonds fell as interest rates rose, All Weather lost more than 90/10, and its own worst fall came then, not in 2008. It took 3.8 years to get back to its old high.
The plain 60/40 is the quiet surprise. It had about the same Sharpe ratio as All Weather (0.80) and grew faster, though it fell further at its worst (29.8%).
What it means for your portfolio
On return alone, Buffett's 90/10 won over most stretches since 2006. The price was a fall of about half in the 2008 crash and more than four years below its old high. All Weather avoided that, then had its own bad run when bonds and stocks fell together.
So the real question is which fall you could sit through without selling. Test both mixes next to the one you hold, over every start date rather than one, and read the worst fall and the time under water as well as the return. Our guide on max drawdown explains how to read those, lazy portfolios backtested puts All Weather next to the three-fund portfolio and others, stocks vs bonds shows what each bond fund did in every crash, and Sharpe vs Sortino vs Calmar explains the risk-adjusted ratios.
Questions
What is Warren Buffett's 90/10 portfolio?
It is the split Buffett described in his 2013 letter to shareholders for money left to his wife: nine-tenths in a low-cost S&P 500 index fund and one-tenth in short-term government bonds. We built it as SPY 90 / SHY 10, rebalanced once a year.
What is in Ray Dalio's All Weather portfolio?
The simplified version for individual investors holds 30% stocks, 40% long-term Treasuries, 15% intermediate Treasuries, 7.5% gold and 7.5% commodities. We used VTI, TLT, IEF, GLD and DBC.
Did All Weather hold up better in 2022?
No. In our test All Weather returned −19.2% in 2022 against −16.7% for 90/10, because its large long-term bond holding fell with stocks as rates rose.
Which one has the better risk-adjusted return?
All Weather. Its Sharpe ratio was 0.81 against 0.64 for 90/10, because it swung far less, even though it grew more slowly.
Why does the test start in 2006?
Because DBC, the commodities fund in All Weather, began trading then. Every fund has to exist on the start date, so the youngest one sets it.
About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.