Myth
Do small caps beat large caps over time?
It depends on the fund and, above all, the start date. From 28 July 2000 IJR grew 9.5% a year against 8.1% for SPY, but IWM trailed SPY and IJR led in only 55.8% of 10-year windows, none ending after November 2019.
The myth, and why people believe it
The claim is that shares of small companies grow faster than shares of large ones if you hold them long enough. A small cap is a company with a small total stock market value (market capitalisation, the share price times the number of shares); small-cap funds hold hundreds of them. A large cap is one of the giants that dominate the S&P 500.
The idea has a respectable history. Academic studies of US stocks back to the 1920s found a size premium: on average, smaller companies earned more than larger ones, which is usually explained as pay for extra risk. Small value funds, which buy small companies that also look cheap on measures like price to book value, combine that with the value premium, and many long-term investors tilt towards them for that reason.
How we tested it
We used funds you can buy rather than academic indexes. IJR tracks the S&P SmallCap 600, which only admits companies with positive earnings. IWM tracks the Russell 2000, a broader small-cap index with no profit test. IJS holds the value half of the S&P SmallCap 600. SPY, which tracks the S&P 500, is the benchmark for large caps. Each fund was held with dividends reinvested from 28 July 2000, the first date all four have prices, to 20 November 2026.
"Beat" means grew faster, over the whole period and over every 10-year stretch, month by month. Before looking at the result, we set the line: the myth is busted if both IJR and IWM grew more slowly than SPY over the whole period and IJR led in fewer than three in ten 10-year windows; proven if both grew at least one percentage point a year faster and IJR led in at least seven in ten windows; otherwise it depends.
How we tested this
The result
It depends on which small-cap fund you mean and, above all, on when you start. IJR grew 9.5% a year against 8.1% for SPY, a gap of +1.4 points. IWM, the broader fund, grew 7.9% a year and finished behind SPY. Over 10-year windows IJR led in 55.8% of them, close to a coin toss.
IJR finished ahead of SPY in 55.8% of 197 rolling 10-year windows (window ends by month). The last window IJR won ended November 2019.
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 28 July 2000 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
The windows are not mixed at random. Almost every 10-year window ending between 2010 and 2018 went to IJR, because those windows contain the years just after the dot-com crash. No 10-year window ending after November 2019 did.
Test IJR IWM IJS $10,000 became (SPY: $77,291) $108,050 $73,615 $108,257 Yearly growth gap vs SPY +1.4 points −0.2 points +1.4 points Ahead over 10 years 55.8% of 197 38.1% of 197 46.7% of 197 Ahead over 20 years 48.1% of 77 23.4% of 77 39.0% of 77
Split the history in half and the answer flips. In the first half, mid-2000 to 2013, IJR grew 9.7% a year while SPY managed 3.3%. In the second half, 2013 to now, SPY grew 13.1% a year against 9.2% for IJR.
- IJR $108,050
- IWM $73,615
- IJS $108,257
- SPY $77,291
Full period: Indices Lab backtest, total return, funds held throughout, 28 July 2000 to 20 November 2026. Hypothetical results: past performance does not predict future returns.
IJR grew more than one point a year faster, but IWM did not, and IJR led in neither fewer than three in ten nor more than seven in ten windows. Under the rule we set, the verdict is it depends.
Where the myth has a point
The whole lead comes from the first few years. Small caps fell less, or even rose, while large caps slumped after the dot-com bubble burst. In recent years the gap ran the other way:
Year IJR IWM IJS SPY 2001 +6.4% +1.8% +11.7% −11.8% 2002 −14.3% −20.4% −14.0% −21.6% 2003 +38.5% +47.9% +39.7% +28.2% 2023 +16.1% +16.8% +14.7% +26.2% 2024 +8.6% +11.4% +7.3% +24.9%
Start the same test in 2004, after that run, and all three small-cap funds trail SPY over the whole period. That is the trap in most "small caps win" and "small caps lose" claims: the start date decides the answer.
Index choice matters too. IJR, whose index screens out companies without profits, finished with far more money than IWM, which holds them. Over the same years IJR grew 9.5% a year and IWM 7.9%. IJS, the small value fund, ended level with IJR, so the value tilt added little on top of the profit screen here.
What it means for your portfolio
Small caps did not reliably beat large caps in the funds people can buy. They swung more (23.0% volatility, the usual measure of how much a value jumps around, against 19.1% for SPY) and fell further at their worst (58.2% against 55.2%). Yet SPY spent longer below an old high, 6.1 years after its 2000 peak, against 3.6 years at most for IJR.
If you hold or plan a small-cap slice, test it over every start date rather than one, and compare the fund's index rules, not only its label. Factor investing tests quality, momentum and low volatility the same way, value vs growth shows the value premium on large funds, equal weight vs market cap looks at tilting the S&P 500 towards its smaller members, and max drawdown explains how to read the falls.
Questions
What is the size premium?
It is the extra return academic studies found for small companies over large ones on average, usually explained as pay for extra risk. In the funds we tested, it showed up in some periods and not in others.
Is IJR or IWM the better small-cap fund?
They track different indexes. IJR's S&P SmallCap 600 only admits companies with positive earnings, while IWM's Russell 2000 has no profit test. In our test IJR grew 9.5% a year and IWM 7.9%.
Did small cap value do better than plain small caps?
Not here. IJS, the value half of the S&P SmallCap 600, ended with about the same money as IJR: $108,257 against $108,050 from $10,000.
How have small caps done in the last three years?
Behind large caps. Over the last three years IJR grew 12.5% a year against 16.3% for SPY.
Why does the test start in 2000?
Because IJS, the youngest of the four funds, began trading then. Every fund has to exist on the start date, so the youngest one sets it.
About this page. Figures on this page come from Indices Lab’s own data, powered by EODHD, and every number is recalculated after each market close; the text is reviewed by a person before it is published. Indices Lab is a research and educational tool: everything here is hypothetical and informational, not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not predict future results. See our methodology.